New Hampshire housing market is stagnating. Some see a silver lining
When New Hampshire’s housing market was at its hottest in recent years, the conversation Josh Greenwald might have had with a client selling their home was simple: List the home, and sit back and wait for the offers.
“All you had to do was list your house for sale, and somebody’s going to want it, you know, and they’ll pay through the nose to get it,” said the Keene Realtor and president of the New Hampshire Association of Realtors.
That “seller’s market” persisted years after the out-of-state buying frenzy in 2020 and 2021 drove a spike in New Hampshire home prices and caused a severe shortage in inventory. Even as prices went higher and listings became more unaffordable for residents, the demand refused to die.
This fall, that might be finally starting to change. Years of high mortgage rates and list prices — in addition to inflation and cost-of-living hardships — have squeezed buyers in New Hampshire, leading to a slowdown in sales.
Homebuying in New England typically falls off in the fall and winter months, picking up with the warmer weather in spring and summer. But this year, the drop-off appears to be exceeding the usual slowdown and is noticeable on the ground, Greenwald says. And the conversations he is having with sellers are more sobering.
“We have to now tell our clients it might take a week or two before we get a showing,” he said. “And they’re like, ‘Well, how come we’ve only had three or four showings?’ I’m like, ‘There’s not as many buyers right now.’”
That conversation often leads in only one direction: Lowering the price. It could be the difference between the house selling or sitting on the market for a year.
As the real estate market heads into winter, new numbers from the New Hampshire Association of Realtors show home prices remain stubbornly high, and affordability is worsening.
Yet the tough news could come with a silver lining, Greenwald says: The state’s housing price frenzy might finally be running out of gas. With enough price corrections, the market could eventually find its elusive balance.
“I consider 2027 to be more of a return to normalcy in the market where buyers have their power back, and I think that that’s the way it ought to be,” he said.
Affordability issues persist
Even as the market appears to be cooling for sellers, it is not exactly a picnic for buyers.
The median price for a single-family home in the state was $543,223 in October, 1.5% higher than the year before, according to the monthly reporting from the state association. Townhouse-condo properties rose by 6% from 12 months before; the median price for one of those properties is now $430,000.
The climbing prices continue to put homeownership out of reach for many families. New Hampshire’s housing affordability index, which weighs the prices of homes against median household income, has dropped 10.2% from a year ago, according to the association.
For single-family homes, the index is now 53. That means the state’s median household income, $106,759, according to the U.S. Census Bureau, is just 53% of the earnings needed to afford the median home price in New Hampshire. The metric assumes families would spend no more than 30% of their income on housing and pay a 20% down payment.
“New Hampshire’s housing market has entered a period of prolonged stagnation,” wrote Rob Dapice, executive director and CEO of New Hampshire Housing, a quasi-state agency, in the agency’s annual report this month. “Rents and home prices may no longer be rising at the extraordinary pace of recent years, but they remain far beyond reach for many residents.”
New Hampshire homes weren’t always so unaffordable. Between 2007 and 2022, the affordability index was at more than 100, meaning for 15 years the median income could afford the median home price. In 2012 and 2013, the index was more than 200.
But skyrocketing prices during the COVID-19 pandemic and an inability for inventory to meet the demand in the years since have widened the gap between what New Hampshire families earn and how homes are priced.
The findings come as interest rates and low inventory continue to plague the state.
Nationally, the average mortgage rate on Tuesday was 7.3%, according to the Mortgage Research Center. For a family buying a home at the state median price of $543,000 and putting down 20%, or $108,600, that would require a monthly payment of about $3,000.
The continuing high prices tell only part of the story. Fewer people in New Hampshire are putting their homes on the market than last year, the data indicates.
And those who put their homes on the market continue to struggle to make a sale, the numbers suggest.
The total number of homes for sale last month is up 18.6% from a year earlier. But that increase measures the cumulative total of all homes that were at some point listed.
The number of pending sales in New Hampshire fell 4.2% last October compared to a year before, while the number of new listings dropped 8.6%.
While more inventory is usually good for prices and buyers, in this case the numbers suggest a glut of homes that are not affordable and not selling — potentially a casualty of the persistently high interest rates.
“It’s not necessarily because many more people are listing their homes,” said Greenwald. “It’s the ones that are on the shelves that are not getting bought.”
Tools to help
As market conditions continue to harm first-time homebuyers, New Hampshire Housing is increasing its attempts to help.
The agency, which helps disburse New Hampshire’s Department of Housing and Urban Development funds, distributed $7.5 million in down-payment assistance to home buyers in the 2027 state fiscal year, a 38.9% increase from the fiscal year before, according to its annual report. It has expanded the number of first-time homebuyers receiving mortgage assistance from 1,000 to 1,345 over the past year.
“This work is rarely glamorous, and it will not command the same attention as tomorrow’s headlines about the next AI breakthrough,” Dapice wrote in the annual report. “But we are proud of every success story we help make possible, and we remain committed to carrying this mission forward.”
Lawmakers have enacted a number of new laws meant to spur housing growth and improve affordability, from expanded rights to build accessory dwelling units to requirements that municipalities allow mixed-use housing in most commercial zones. Many are just starting to take effect, and new housing made possible by the laws could be years away.
New Hampshire Housing is providing funding to help support multifamily developments in the state; the agency used low-income housing tax credits to help build 850 new apartment units in the last year, the report states.
Greenwald, like many real estate agents, sees inventory as the primary obstacle. He compared the housing experience to musical chairs: Buyers can try to secure a dwindling number of seats, but the better solution is to add more chairs.
“I think that is going to take many years to bear fruit,” Greenwald said of the legislative approach.
For now, he added, the short-term relief might come from supply and demand.
“As we see inventory levels increase, we have more buyer options, and that’s going to (tamp) down price increases,” he said. “Which is going to have a snowball effect.”