Home Part of States Newsroom
News
Utility regulators order up audit of Xcel’s billing, customer service issues

Share

Utility regulators order up audit of Xcel’s billing, customer service issues

Nov 20, 2026 | 9:23 am ET
By Brian Martucci
Utility regulators order up audit of Xcel’s billing, customer service issues
Description
Xcel Energy headquarters in Minneapolis. (Photo by Getty Images)

Minnesota utility regulators on Thursday ordered Xcel Energy to undergo an outside audit amid mounting scrutiny of the Minneapolis-based company’s billing and customer service issues.

The Minnesota Department of Commerce will oversee the audit, which will be paid for by Xcel and completed by the end of 2027, according to a verbal order from the five-member Public Utilities Commission at Thursday’s public hearing. A post-audit report will be made public, commissioners said. 

A ratepayer advocate welcomed the audit and said they were hopeful it marked a turning point in the Public Utilities Commission’s more than year-long investigation into an electric utility that serves more than 1.5 million customers across the state.

“The PUC proceeding demonstrates what we have been hearing from Xcel customers for years — customers are not receiving the service that Xcel promises, and that is guaranteed under Minnesota law,” said Annie Levenson-Falk, executive director of the Citizens Utility Board of Minnesota.

Xcel spokesperson Medgan Boldt said in an email to the Reformer that the company takes the situation seriously and has already made progress on “improving our billing processes, reducing backlogs and addressing the underlying issues affecting customer billing.” 

Dozens of Xcel customers, including the cities of St. Paul, St. Cloud and St. Louis Park, complained to the commission this year about billing errors that have resulted in mounting late fees or missing credits for onsite solar energy production.

At Thursday’s hearing, commissioners also raised concerns about Xcel’s customer service. 

At one point, they played a recorded phone call between an Xcel customer in arrears and a Public Utilities Commission mediator on one end and two Xcel representatives on the other. The company representatives appeared dismissive of the customer’s predicament, questioned the mediator’s identity and appeared unaware of basic facts about Minnesota’s Energy Assistance Program or state law governing utility bill payment plans. 

Xcel is taking “additional action” on customer service quality, Boldt said.

“Our customer service representatives are receiving additional training and tools to deliver more timely, empathetic service to customers when they call for help. That includes additional information on energy assistance programs,” she said. 

Other Xcel customers’ complaints hint at more widespread billing and accounting issues.

A September complaint from St. Paul Mayor Kaohly Her detailed seven separate billing issues over the past two years, including changes to service period cutoff dates that in one case resulted in 12 billing statements coming in a single month; misapplication of payments resulting in late fees; and delayed credit refunds, to the tune of $20,000 at one city facility. 

Her said city staff have had to contact Xcel representatives “hundreds of times” about the issues.

“Xcel representatives have generally been responsive and appear to be making good-faith efforts, but even they have often been unable to fully explain the root causes of these errors, which suggests the issues may lie deeper within Xcel’s billing systems and processes than individual staff are equipped to address,” she wrote.

Commissioner Hwikwon Ham suggested Thursday that he and his colleagues would seek to hold Xcel executives accountable for the lapses.

Xcel gave CEO Bob Frenzel a $3 million bonus in 2025, up from $1.2 million in 2024, according to the Star Tribune — in part because the company exceeded customer satisfaction targets tied to executive pay after falling short the three years prior. But the improvement came after Xcel switched from the widely used JD Power residential customer survey to an “internal customer experience index” that gave the company a “much larger sample size of surveys [and] a much more granular look at results,” a spokesperson told the Star Tribune.

Xcel critics say it’s a bad look for the company to boost pay for top executives amid an extraordinary investigation into how it treats customers.

“Regulators were right to send a clear message that Xcel needs to actually provide quality service and customer satisfaction, not just pay its CEO a bonus for it,” Karlee Weinmann, research and communications manager for the Energy and Policy Institute, told the Reformer. 

The Energy and Policy Institute has been sharply critical of Xcel and other for-profit utility companies for earning what it says are excessive profits at ratepayer expense. The group released a report in March that showed Xcel with a higher profit margin than most other U.S. utilities.

Boldt cited a nearly 90% reduction in “outstanding residential billing referrals and rate change requests” and significant reductions in canceled invoices and “aged billing issues” as evidence Xcel is moving in the right direction. But she said the company “has more work to do.”

“Despite these improvements, too many customers are still experiencing billing and customer service issues. We heard the Commission and will collaborate closely with the third-party auditor on ways to improve,” she said.