Home Part of States Newsroom
News
Court further delays lead azide detonation at Middletown plant

Share

Court further delays lead azide detonation at Middletown plant

Nov 20, 2026 | 6:06 pm ET
By Cami Koons
Court further delays lead azide detonation at Middletown plant
Description
A sign sits along the fence of the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant on Nov. 20, 2026 in Middletown, Iowa where the Army intends to detonate a degraded explosive material. (Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images)

The detonation of a lead-based explosive material planned for Monday in southeast Iowa will be held off until the court can rule on a lawsuit over the federal permit for the action. 

The lawsuit, filed on behalf of Iowa environmental groups, alleged the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency did not adequately consider the human health or environmental outcomes of the detonation of 68 barrels of lead azide, nor did it properly consider “less dangerous alternatives.”

The lawsuit, filed Thursday in the U.S. Appellate Court for the Eighth District, asked the court to either rule or issue an administrative stay on the permit before detonation, which was originally planned for Nov. 20 at noon. On Thursday evening, acting Secretary of the Army, Hon. Adam Telle announced the detonation would be postponed until Monday, Nov. 23. 

Following the postponement, Gov. Kim Reynolds said in a statement she had asked Telle to delay the detonation. 

Iowans, lawmakers, public officials and environmental groups began expressing concern about the potential effects from the detonation of degraded lead azide at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant after the Army released maps showing the potential spread of air and dust containing lead particles. 

Some lawmakers were concerned by the short period of time between when the Army made the public announcement and informed the state and when the detonation was scheduled. They, like concerned Iowans and the petitioning environmental groups, questioned if the planned detonation and associated release of lead was the best course of action. 

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Region 7 Director Jim Macy sent a letter to Reynolds Friday afternoon, detailing the collaboration between federal agencies to prioritize “health and safety” of all Americans living within the potentially impacted area. Depending on the weather, plume modeling has indicated the impacted area could stretch to parts of Illinois. 

Court further delays lead azide detonation at Middletown plant
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Region 7 Director Jim Macy. (Photo courtesy of EPA)

In his letter to Reynolds, Macy said EPA was working with the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services and the U.S. Department of Defense to “ensure” the controlled detonation was “conducted in the safest manner possible.” 

“All agencies involved are prepared to take the most extreme mitigation measures available to ensure there is no risk to the public and any disruptions are minimized,” Macy wrote in the letter, which was sent to the Iowa Capital Dispatch.

Iowa Environmental Council, Sierra Club Iowa Chapter and Earthjustice – the groups suing EPA over the permit – held a news conference Friday to discuss the lawsuit. 

Michael Schmidt with the Iowa Environmental Council said events leading up to the lawsuit have “demonstrated that we cannot rely on the federal government, including the Army and EPA, to adequately inform Iowans” about the risks posed by the planned detonation.

“As such, today we are calling on our state leaders, including Governor Reynolds, to take control of the communication regarding this potential detonation,” Schmidt said. “Iowans deserve a transparent, coordinated, and effective response to this unprecedented event.” 

The governor’s office did not respond to a request for comment Friday.

Considering the alternatives

The letter from Macy summarized the work between EPA and Army since March — when the Army identified the degraded state of the lead azide — which informed EPA’s decision to grant the permit.

Macy wrote that the Army “concluded the only viable option was a controlled detonation in place with extensive mitigation measures” after “considering and exhausting all other proposed alternatives.” 

The alternatives described in the letter include: treating the barrels with a chemical, using heavy earth-moving equipment to build a structure around the containers, moving the lead azide to IAAAP’s existing open detonation unit and leaving the 68 drums in place. 

Each alternative, according to Macy’s letter, presented “an unacceptable safety risk” with a high likelihood of accidental detonation of the explosive material due to the “advanced crystallization.” 

Environmental groups, in their lawsuit, allege EPA had an “arbitrary acceptance of the Army’s dismissal of treatment alternatives” that would have avoided a “blast plume.” 

Wally Taylor, legal chair of the Sierra Club Iowa Chapter, said in the news conference Friday it was “discouraging that the EPA did not require those alternatives to be properly examined.” 

“We think that the Army has done the right thing, at least initially, in postponing the proposed detonation, but they still plan to do it,” Taylor said. “We are asking the court to send this whole process – the permit, the plan to detonate – back for further review, and let’s do it right.” 

In a post on X announcing the postponement, Telle said the Monday postponement was the “latest possible moment” for the detonation “prior to a forecasted temperature drop, which would risk further destabilization of the material.” 

Court further delays lead azide detonation at Middletown plant
Map from Nov. 18 showing the potential area that could have lead particles in the air following a now postponed detonation of lead azide in Middletown. (Photo via U.S. Army)

Asked Friday if the environmental groups worried that the explosive material would detonate on its own while the issue played out in the court, Taylor said “we need more assurance that there really is that danger and that immediacy that requires detonation right now.” 

“It seems to me that that’s a pretty lame excuse when that material has been there for years and years, and now they’re delaying another few days until Monday,” Taylor said. 

DOJ expected to file this weekend 

The administrative stay means that it would be unlawful for the Army to proceed with the detonation under the EPA permit questioned by the lawsuit, according to Thien Chau, a senior attorney with Earthjustice.

The U.S. Department of Justice filed a motion in the case on Friday telling the court it intends to file an opposition, on behalf of EPA, before Nov. 22. 

The motion acknowledges the administrative stay and the Army’s Nov. 23 detonation date, then says that “in qualifying emergency situations” EPA regulations authorize the Army “to implement waste treatment activity without an EPA permit” when there is “an immediate threat to human health, public safety, property, or the environment.”

Chau, said it wasn’t appropriate for him to speculate why the DOJ included that in their motion, but he said the regulation cited is “an extraordinary and extreme backstop for situations where there are truly no other things that could be done.” 

“It’s an incredibly high bar, and we strongly urge the army not to rely on it,” Chau said. 

A spokesperson with the Army Sustainment Command did not respond Friday to a message asking if the Army intended to proceed with the Monday detonation, even if the administrative stay were in place. 

Communication

Part of the lawsuit, and public backlash over the planned detonation centered on a perceived lack of communication between the Army and relevant stakeholders. 

The letter from Macy to Reynolds included a timeline of actions between EPA and the Army, and with the public. 

Court further delays lead azide detonation at Middletown plant
Map from Nov. 18 showing the potential area that could have lead dust following a now postponed detonation of lead azide in Middletown. (Photo via U.S. Army)

Between April and September, EPA issued three emergency permits allowing Iowa Army Ammunition Plant to continue to store the material safely, while it evaluated potential treatment options. The letter to Reynolds shows that for each of these permits, notice was sent to the Iowa congressional delegation, state lawmakers, and local officials.

The same group of officials was notified Nov. 13 when EPA granted IAAAP the emergency treatment permit allowing the intentional detonation. 

State officials have said they were not aware of the planned detonation until the U.S. Army put out a public announcement with the original detonation schedule, air disbursement and dust deposition maps. 

Post detonation 

 The letter also explained the role EPA will play post detonation to monitor potential impacts.

According to the letter, and field team from EPA’s Region 7 has been in Middletown since Nov. 16 to conduct independent monitoring and sampling, in addition to the monitoring and sampling being collected by the Army. 

“Current modeling predicts that airborne lead levels may rise for a few hours as the plume passes,” Macy wrote in the letter. “The assessment is that this elevated, but low, level of lead will last for only a few hours.” 

EPA staff are also working to evaluate impacts from the plume to drinking water sources and surrounding watersheds. Macy wrote in the letter that if testing shows “potentially impacted water systems and waterbodies” the EPA and the Army will work to monitor drinking water and provide filters for homeowners on public water supply systems with elevated levels of lead.  

“My team is proudly committed to doing everything in our power to pursue clean, air, land, and water for all Americans,” Macy wrote in the letter to Reynolds. “We stand ready to provide additional support, and we will continue to engage with state and local officials and the public to provide additional updates in a timely manner.”

Reynolds’ office did not respond to a request for comment on the letter.