Complaint stays alive against dark money group over $60K donation to Engling campaign
An election law dispute between the top candidates for the Republican secretary of state nomination over an improper $60,000 contribution has been dropped, while action is still possible against the dark money group affiliated with U.S. Jim Banks that gave the money.
At issue is a June contribution to Republican Max Engling’s campaign from Hoosier Leadership for America Inc. A complaint filed by Knox County Clerk David Shelton, who finished second to Engling at this year’s state GOP convention, alleged the group and Engling’s campaign violated state law limiting corporations and labor organizations to a maximum of $5,000 a year in contributions to statewide office candidates.
Shelton asked the Indiana Election Commission on Friday to dismiss the complaint against Engling, saying he was satisfied with evidence that his campaign had refunded the improper donation within a couple weeks.
The commission granted that dismissal along with Shelton’s request to keep active the complaint against Hoosier Leadership for America.
That organization is registered with state and federal agencies as a nonprofit corporation with a Fort Wayne address, which allows it to keep the sources of its money secret — the reason why such entities are commonly referred to as dark-money groups.
The ad-tracking firm AdImpact reported Hoosier Leadership for America spent $5.2 million on broadcast advertising during this year’s primary campaign against Republican state senators who opposed President Donald Trump’s demands for Indiana congressional redistricting.
Shelton said after Friday’s commission meeting that he believed the group should face fines for violating state campaign finance laws.
“I still think they are liable,” Shelton told the Capital Chronicle. “They should know better than that. They’ve been in the game long enough.”
Law makes corporations abide limits
The commission on Friday did not take up the complaint against Hoosier Leadership for America as a state Election Division staff oversight meant it had not received sufficient notice. No date was set for when the commission would consider action.
Engling campaign says it returned $60K donation from dark money group
The Capital Chronicle sent an email seeking comment to the person identified in TV advertising purchases as the organization’s treasurer, Charles Gantt of the Massachusetts-based political advisory group Bulldog Compliance.
Prominent conservative attorney Jim Bopp, who is representing Engling’s campaign, said the burden is on the corporation making political contributions to make sure they are abiding by the state’s limits.
An example given during Friday’s meeting would be a corporation giving $2,000 each to 10 candidates would exceed the $5,000 total limit without the individual candidates being aware.
“The statute is clear that the committee that received (the contribution) is not responsible, but the corporation,” Bopp said.
Dispute over delay in hearing complaints
The Election Commission — made up of two Republicans and two Democrats — faced controversy for not taking up before Election Day the complaint against Engling and two filed against Democratic Secretary of State-elect Beau Bayh.
Lincoln Party candidate Greg Ballard unsuccessfully sought a court order forcing a pre-Election Day meeting, arguing the commission was abdicating its duty to enforce election laws. A Marion County judge this week dismissed Ballard’s lawsuit upon his request, according to court records.
The decision to wait until Friday for any commission action rested with commission Chair Beth Boyce, who is the Johnson County Republican chair. She declined to comment Friday to the Capital Chronicle about her reasoning.
Commission members voted unanimously to dismiss complaints against Bayh’s campaign alleging it received unreported in-kind contributions in connection with events hosted by Democratic Party organization and that printed materials promoting Bayh lacked required disclaimers.
A Republican activist who filed one of the Bayh complaints requested it be dropped, while the other person lodging a complaint did not attend Friday’s meeting to pursue the matter.
Shelton filed legal arguments in support of Ballard’s lawsuit and said Friday that the commission needed to step up and enforce the campaign finance laws.
“Hoosiers deserve to know who the funding comes from for their candidates,” he said. “We’ve got to do what we can to maintain the integrity of our election processes here in Indiana, including campaign finances and dark money is coming in from who knows where.”