Home Part of States Newsroom
News
Nebraska federal court nominee Eric Hamilton faces criticism and support during hearing

Share

Nebraska federal court nominee Eric Hamilton faces criticism and support during hearing

Nov 18, 2026 | 6:54 pm ET
By Cindy Gonzalez
Nebraska federal court nominee Eric Hamilton faces criticism and support during hearing
Description
The Senate Judiciary Committee held a hearing with Trump judicial nominees, including Eric Hamilton, who is up for a lifetime appointment to the U.S. District Court of Nebraska. (Photo courtesy of David Talukdar/Getty Images)

A former Nebraska solicitor general who is President Donald Trump’s pick to fill a federal judgeship faced questions Wednesday during a confirmation hearing before a Senate committee.

Nebraska federal court nominee Eric Hamilton faces criticism and support during hearing
Eric Hamilton, 38 and raised in Omaha, appeared at a judicial nomination hearing before a Senate Judiciary Committee Wednesday on Capitol Hill. (Photo courtesy of U.S. Department of Justice)

Nebraska’s two U.S. senators appeared in support of Eric Hamilton’s nomination to the U.S. District Court of Nebraska — offering a starkly different picture from an opposition letter by a coalition of civil rights, economic justice and numerous other advocacy groups.

The Judiciary Committee took no immediate action. If approved, the nomination will go to the Senate floor for a vote. 

Hamilton, 38, is a sixth-generation Nebraskan who served as an associate counsel to the president during Trump’s first administration. He responded to lawmaker questions during a group interview involving a half-dozen Trump nominees also up for a lifetime judicial appointment. Others represented Texas, Indiana, North Carolina and South Carolina.

‘What a legacy’

Sen. Richard Durbin, an Illinois Democrat and ranking member of the committee, voiced concern about Hamilton, recounting a federal judge’s 2025 rebuke of a federal defense team he oversaw during a case involving the attempted dismantling of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. 

Durbin cited the judge’s written doubts whether the defense could be “trusted to tell the truth about anything.”

“What a legacy,” Durbin said. 

Hamilton would replace Judge Robert Rossiter, an Obama appointee who is taking senior status on the federal bench. In remarks to the committee, Hamilton thanked Trump and Nebraska U.S. Sens. Deb Fischer and Pete Ricketts, both Republicans, for putting forth his name.

He told the committee chaired by Sen. Charles Grassley, R-Iowa, that his greatest gift was being born to his parents. His dad died earlier this year and, he said, his mom was watching virtually from Omaha.

President Donald Trump points into the crowd after headlining a midterms rally in Grand Island, Nebraska, on Oct. 5, 2026, at the Nebraska State Fairgrounds, with thousands in attendance. (Photo by Zach Wendling/Nebraska Examiner)
President Donald Trump points into the crowd after headlining a midterms rally in Grand Island, Nebraska, on Oct. 5, 2026. (Photo by Zach Wendling/Nebraska Examiner)

If appointed, Hamilton said, he would follow the example of his first legal mentor, Judge Thomas Hardiman of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 3rd Circuit, whom he clerked for after graduating from Stanford Law School in 2013.

Sen. Richard Blumenthal, a Connecticut Democrat on the Judiciary Committee, peppered Hamilton and the other nominees about who won the 2020 popular vote and whether there was an “attack” on the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021.

He said he was testing their judicial independence and objectivity over “political loyalty.” 

Is there anyone on this panel who is willing to say the Capitol was attacked on Jan. 6, 2021? ... Nobody? It’s a sad day.

– U.S. Sen. Richard Blumenthal at a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing

Hamilton generally agreed with other nominees who answered before him. “Joe Biden was certified as the winner of the 2020 election when the electoral votes were tabulated,” he said.

Asked by Blumenthal about the Jan. 6  “attack” on the Capitol, two nominees instead used what they said was the Supreme Court’s description: a “breach of the Capitol.” Following two who spoke before him, Hamilton said he agreed with their description. They also said that they condemn that day’s violence.

The echo of responses spurred Blumenthal to ask, “Is there anyone on this panel who is willing to say the Capitol was attacked on Jan. 6, 2021?”

“Nobody? It’s a sad day.”

Letters of support

Raised in Omaha, Hamilton since 2025 has served as deputy assistant attorney general for the Federal Programs Branch of the Justice Department’s Civil Division, which defends the federal government in litigation.

The committee received multiple letters of support for Hamilton from organizations including former Department of Justice officials, former Hardiman law clerks and the staff of Nebraska Attorney General Mike Hilgers, where Hamilton once worked.

The coalition that outlined objections to Hamilton’s lifetime seat comprised 13 organizations including the Alliance for Justice, National Women’s Law Center, Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights and Lawyers for Good Government.  

In the statement, the coalition noted that Hamilton faced bar misconduct complaints in three jurisdictions, with two of those still pending, including before Nebraska’s highest court.

Nebraska federal court nominee Eric Hamilton faces criticism and support during hearing
U.S. Sen. Deb Fischer, R-Neb. June 6, 2025. (Zach Wendling/Nebraska Examiner)

It said people of color in Nebraska are disproportionately affected by the fair administration of justice in federal courts and would be “harmed” by Hamilton’s confirmation prior to resolution of the ethics charges.

“We believe he does not possess the moral character and fitness necessary to serve as a federal judge,” the group stated in a two-page letter. 

“Hamilton has chosen to side with the Trump administration above all else — even when that loyalty required misconduct to further the continued dismantling of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau,” the coalition wrote.

 Fischer, on the other side, said Hamilton “has shown himself to be a capable, sober minded legal professional in many capacities” and in “high stakes” litigation. 

She told the committee she was struck by a recent conversation in which Hamilton displayed legal knowledge and “enthusiasm for upholding the law.”

Ricketts said he has known Hamilton — a graduate of Millard West High School and the University of Nebraska-Lincoln — since Hamilton was 18 years old and both were getting involved in politics.

Nebraska federal court nominee Eric Hamilton faces criticism and support during hearing
U.S. Sen. Pete Ricketts, Sept. 1, 2026. (Erin Bamer/Nebraska Examiner)

The recently reelected Ricketts told the committee that Nebraska’s motto is “the Good Life,” and that he believes Hamilton “will continue to represent and protect the good life in my state.”

He said that Hamilton defended bills passed by the state Legislature, including a law to “protect preborn babies after 12 weeks.”

Hamilton also served as an assistant solicitor general for Texas.

In announcing his nomination on Truth Social in October, Trump said Hamilton has done a “phenomenal job as the Deputy Assistant Attorney General for the Federal Programs Branch, defending our Administration’s most important Policies in Court.”

Judge’s scolding

The Hamilton critics took particular aim at his actions as a senior federal government lawyer defending Russell Vought in Vought’s efforts to shutter the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, one of the government’s key consumer protection agencies. Vought was CFPD acting director during the  lawsuit filed by employee unions.

The coalition noted federal Judge Amy Berman Jackson’s comments regarding Hamilton’s team. She described its account as “highly misleading, if not intentionally false” and wrote that she was left with little confidence the defense “can be trusted to tell the truth about anything.”

A legal watchdog group, the Legal Accountability Center, last year filed complaints with grievance committees of bar associations, saying that Hamilton and two associates made false statements in the case.