Home Part of States Newsroom
News
North Dakota Ethics Commission sues Attorney General Wrigley over ‘void’ advisory opinion

Share

North Dakota Ethics Commission sues Attorney General Wrigley over ‘void’ advisory opinion

Nov 18, 2026 | 5:53 pm ET
By Jack Dura
North Dakota Ethics Commission sues Attorney General Wrigley over ‘void’ advisory opinion
Description
Ethics Commissioners Jared Huibregtse, left, and Mark Western, center, listen to Ethics Commission Chair Pam Sharp announce a lawsuit against North Dakota Attorney General Drew Wrigley on Nov. 18, 2026. (Photo by Jack Dura/North Dakota Monitor)

The North Dakota Ethics Commission is challenging Attorney General Drew Wrigley’s authority to void a commission advisory opinion last year.

The five-member ethics panel voted unanimously Wednesday to file a lawsuit in state district court in Burleigh County. The commission is asking the court to clarify that the judicial branch is the only state entity with authority to declare the action of another state entity void, Chair Pam Sharp said.

“The law demands clarity when one government entity seeks to void the decisions of another government entity,” Sharp said. “Our system of constitutional government requires the courts to provide that clarity.”

The lawsuit appeared online Wednesday.

North Dakota attorney general voids ethics opinion, says agency lacked authority

In a text message Wednesday, Wrigley said his office had not been served with the lawsuit. He released a critical opinion about the ethics panel nearly a year ago, which he said “calls into question the timing of the Commission’s lawsuit.” 

“One could reasonably conclude that this lawsuit is retaliatory in nature, extending a pattern of conduct across recent years, a pattern that raises significant ethical issues with regard to the conduct of individuals associated with the Commission,” Wrigley said. 

North Dakota voters in 2018 created the Ethics Commission, whose members are appointed by the governor and Senate majority and minority leaders. The attorney general is an elected position. Wrigley won reelection earlier this month.

The lawsuit concerns a June 2025 advisory opinion the ethics panel issued to then-Sen. Josh Boschee, D-Fargo, who had asked about whether a candidate can use campaign funds to pay for caregiving or security expenses. The commission said each is permissible in some instances. 

The ethics panel issues advisory panels to requestors, such as lawmakers, for guidance on prospective, ethics-related actions.

Secretary of State Michael Howe subsequently asked the attorney general for an opinion on the panel’s related authority, saying the ethics panel’s opinion “raises significant concerns regarding the legal and administrative boundaries between our offices.” Gov. Kelly Armstrong also has questioned the range of the Ethics Commission’s authority on advisory opinions.

Governor questions scope of Ethics Commission authority

In December, Wrigley issued his opinion to Howe saying the Ethics Commission “made unauthorized and expansive legal conclusions” in its opinion “without legal authority to do so.” He also said the ethics panel’s advisory opinion is “void” and “has no legal effect.”

Ethics Commissioner Mark Western said Wednesday, “We believe the law provides that an attorney general may not void the acts of another entity of state government. Only a district judge may do so.”

The commission wrote three times to the attorney general’s office in April and May seeking clarification on Wrigley’s opinion, with no responses, Western said. In a text message screen shot included in court papers, Wrigley sent an image of a Google result for the definition of the word “nullity” to Sharp in May. 

Western said the dispute isn’t about personalities but seeks “judicial clarification about where the attorney general’s office authority ends and the Ethics Commission authority ends.” 

The lawsuit asks the court, in part, to declare the AG lacks legal authority to nullify or void an action of the Ethics Commission, not just advisory opinions.

Sharp called advisory opinions “a strong tool to provide proactive and clear guidance when ethics requirements, statute and commission rules are not straightforward.” The panel discussed one request Wednesday from Rep. Mike Motschenbacher, R-Bismarck, related to his roles as a lawmaker and executive director of the North Dakota Gaming Alliance.

North Dakota Ethics Commission sues Attorney General Wrigley over ‘void’ advisory opinion
Attorney General Drew Wrigley listens during a North Dakota Industrial Commission meeting on Oct. 30, 2026. (Photo by Jacob Orledge/North Dakota Monitor)

Wrigley issued his opinion on the Ethics Commission nearly a year ago. The commission filed the lawsuit now because of its attempts earlier this year to communicate with Wrigley’s office and did not want to do anything before the November general election, Sharp said.

Sharp read a statement announcing the lawsuit near the end of the commission’s meeting and took reporters’ questions. The meeting earlier dealt with routine updates and three executive sessions closed to the public related to Wrigley’s opinion, various complaints and an inquiry into the North Dakota Development Fund.

Reporter Michael Achterling contributed to this report.

Reach North Dakota Monitor reporter Jack Dura at [email protected].