Judge suggests wolf captor Cody Roberts’ felony case will proceed to trial
GREEN RIVER—A Sweetwater County judge on Wednesday told Cody Roberts’ defense attorney that his interpretation of state law as it relates to predators “goes too far,” a suggestion that the Daniel resident’s felony animal cruelty charge is headed toward a March jury trial.
District Court Judge Richard Lavery did not rule from the bench after a 2 1/2-hour hearing on a motion to dismiss the case and exclude an expert witness. A written decision is forthcoming, he said.
But Lavery made it clear that he wasn’t persuaded by a primary argument posed by Roberts’ attorney, Robert Piper: Specifically, that there is a “specific, clearly enumerated exception” in Wyoming statute that exempts the “hunting, capture, killing or destruction of any predatory animal” from the state’s animal cruelty laws.
“It just seems a bridge too far that the state can’t pursue [charges],” Lavery told the courtroom. There’s “at least a space,” he added, for Sublette County Prosecuting Attorney Clayton Melinkovich to present evidence in pursuit of a conviction.
On Feb. 29, 2024, Roberts took a muzzled wolf into the Green River Bar in Daniel for hours, appearing to make a joke out of the injured animal’s plight in photographs taken that night. The Wyoming Game and Fish Department fined him $250 for possession of warm-blooded wildlife, declining to send the case to court in pursuit of stiffer penalties. When photos and videos became public about a month later, the incident incited global outrage and condemnation that rattled the small western Wyoming community.
Communicating about the incident in 2024, Wyoming wildlife managers also cited a predatory animal exemption in the animal cruelty laws. Last legislative session, lawmakers also passed a bill that stiffened penalties for tormenting or torturing captured animals that included predator species.
But Sublette County law enforcement officials said from the onset that they were pursuing their own prosecution. Last summer, Melinkovich convened a grand jury that indicted the 44-year-old Daniel resident on a felony animal cruelty charge that carries with it a prison sentence of up to two years.
Roberts pleaded not guilty in November. Alone, sporting a mustache and wearing a suit coat during Wednesday’s proceedings, the defendant never spoke. All parties appeared virtually before Lavery, who sat in his chambers.
Expert witness
The first hour of Wednesday’s proceedings focused on a motion from Piper that sought to exclude a potential expert witness in the state’s prosecution, Wyoming wolf biologist Ken Mills.
Mills testified during the hearing. After cross examining the biologist, Piper argued he lacked the credentials to judge the behavior of a wolf in an unusual indoors environment. Mills has only published one peer-reviewed article about wolf-human interaction, the attorney ascertained through questioning before taking issue with suspected pending testimony he described as a “video necropsy.”
“There was no necropsy,” Piper said. ”There can be no assessment of suffering.”
Being examined by Melinkovich, Mills testified that he’s personally handled 250 to 300 wolves over his career and that a “quarter to a third” of those animals were not chemically immobilized but instead physically restrained. He said he was acquainted with how they behaved when they were subdued, and that most wolves would “submit” but also promptly flee once restraints were removed and they had the chance to get away.
Melinkovich seized on that point: “Not a single one of them stuck around — that’s the point,” he said. “Your honor, I would suggest that Mr. Mills testimony is highly relevant.”
The wolf in the Green River Bar appeared languid and was lying down for an extended period of time, according to an eyewitness. Retired Yellowstone wolf biologist Doug Smith told WyoFile that its behavior suggested that the animal was “recovering from severe injury” with “internal organ damage.”
Lavery did not give a clear indication on how he’d rule about Mills’ status as an expert witness.
Discussing dismissal
Arguing for the case’s dismissal, Piper described the entirety of the wolf’s time in Roberts’ possession as being a long period of “capture.” That’s a word used in the statutory language providing exceptions to animal cruelty for predatory animals. If Roberts could be charged, then so could bow hunters or others who might inadvertently prolong animals’ suffering, he said.
“As the court is well aware, lawful and moral are not synonyms,” Piper said.
Melinkovich has maintained that Roberts’ alleged torment of the wolf doesn’t meet the predatory animal exemption because it was in his possession. The animal cruelty laws apply to all animals, he said.
“A wolf is in fact an animal,” Melinkovich said. “A predator is in fact an animal. Wildlife is in fact an animal. A pest is in fact an animal. All of which are protected by [animal cruelty laws].”
Roberts’ trial is set for March 9 in Sublette County District Court, and is scheduled to last five days.
Lavery told the courtroom that he plans to summon between 90 and 100 jurors. The prosecuting and defense attorneys discussed working together on a questionnaire that will help them weed out jurists and select the panel that will decide the case.