Home Part of States Newsroom
News
AG Murrill won’t obey judge’s order to apologize to SEC

Share

AG Murrill won’t obey judge’s order to apologize to SEC

Nov 18, 2026 | 7:22 pm ET
AG Murrill won’t obey judge’s order to apologize to SEC
Description
Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill speaks at a news conference Wednesday, Sept. 30, 2026, announcing a lawsuit challenging abortion shield laws in Democratic-led states. Joining Murrill were Attorneys General Steve Marshall of Alabama, left, and Tim Griffin of Arkansas, whose states are also plaintiffs in the case. (Photo by Piper Hutchinson/Louisiana Illuminator)

Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill said she won’t comply with a federal judge’s order to apologize to the Southeastern Conference for alleging the league’s lawyers fabricated citations in a recent court filing.

The caustic exchange among opposing attorneys is the latest drama to unfold in the conference’s lawsuit against Louisiana State University for its attempt to place former pro players on its sports teams. The SEC has threatened to remove LSU as a member school, and Murrill and her office were named co-defendants in the case. 

AL.com reported Wednesday that U.S. District Judge Annemarie Axon, appointed to Alabama’s Northern District Court by President Trump in 2017, ordered Murrill and LSU to issue news releases with a “robust, heartfelt” apology to the SEC for claiming that its citations were “hallucinated,” a term that typically applies to material generated by artificial intelligence.

Citations to previous court decisions typically provide the foundation of the arguments attorneys make in legal proceedings.

“They were maligning your reputation and character,” Axon said about the language defendants used in one of their responses filed with the court.

“I cannot and will not apologize for my lawyers doing their job, and it is improper for an Alabama federal judge to compel speech from the State of Louisiana,” Murrill said in a social media post a few hours later. “The SEC made an egregious citation error. Their inability to explain that error is their problem, not Louisiana’s.” 

“This University of Alabama alumni judge needs to quit playing SEC politics and rule on the lack of subject matter jurisdiction,” Gov. Jeff Landry wrote in his own post. “It is a frivolous case that has wasted both the court’s time and the State’s.” 

Axon received her undergraduate and law degrees from Alabama. 

The judge’s letter followed Wednesday’s hearing in her Birmingham courtroom. That fight escalated this week when LSU added former pro player RJ Luis to its basketball roster after a state judge ordered them to do so. The SEC rebuked the decision, calling it inconsistent with the expectations of a SEC member school, but agreed not to punish LSU for it. 

NCAA and SEC rules prohibit athletes who have played professional sports from competing, but athletes who graduated high school in 2022 and later went pro have sued to return to college. They were the only class left out of NCAA rule changes in June that allowed athletes to play for five years rather than just four. 

Attorney Scott Schneider, an education and employment law expert with federal court experience, said Murrill’s response risks Axon calling her and Solicitor General Ben Aguiñaga, who LSU’s attorney said in Wednesday’s hearing wrote the brief alleging hallucinations, into court to explain themselves. 

Murrill posted online a letter she said she sent to Axon after the hearing, saying that being forced to issue an apology amounts to compelled speech and is a violation of the First Amendment. 

“Any time the government, including the court, is telling you what to say, it certainly raises constitutional questions,” said Scott Sternberg, an attorney who specializes in First Amendment issues. “You know, lawyers are held to a different standard. I think the real question here is whether requiring a press release is a bridge too far, and I’m not sure I’ve ever seen a case like that before.”