State Approves Rate ‘Freeze’ for National Grid Gas Customers, With Strings Attached
In a unanimous vote Thursday, New York state energy regulators approved a plan from the utility National Grid to extend its current downstate gas rates for an additional year and tack expenses onto future bills.
The plan will allow National Grid to spend about $1.7 billion upgrading its infrastructure in New York City and Long Island over a year, and pay for that spending with a mix of accounting maneuvers and future surcharges rather than by immediately hiking rates. Much of that sum will go toward replacing aging pipes. (The goal is to prevent leaks, but some experts see it as a waste.)
Pitched as a rate “freeze,” the plan will take effect next April. After it expires, in spring 2028, National Grid will enact a 2 to 3 percent bill surcharge, adding an average of more than $50 a year to customers’ heating bills, according to filings.
National Grid can still seek additional rate hikes for 2028 onward, and is expected to initiate that process as soon as the next few weeks.
Watchdog groups, the New York City mayor’s office, nearly 30 state lawmakers, and a state office tasked with protecting utility customers had all slammed the proposal in public comments, saying it would effectively hike rates without the usual level of scrutiny.
But the seven-member commission that regulates New York’s energy system, called the Public Service Commission, almost approved the company’s plan without discussion at its Thursday meeting. The item was originally on a “consent” agenda, which is typically reserved for non-controversial items that commissioners approve in a large batch at the end of their meeting.
Commission chair Rory Christian said he moved it to the main agenda “out of a desire to address several misconceptions.” He said National Grid’s plan faced the same “rigorous review” as any other proposal before the commission, and that it offered a “creative way to keep money in people’s pockets.”
The commission largely accepted the plan as written, with one exception: The company will have to keep fixing pipe leaks at the current rate, rather than easing targets as it had sought.
National Grid cheered the plan’s approval, saying it would provide “immediate meaningful financial relief into 2028” for nearly 2 million customers.
The decision “means customers can expect stable costs for the safe and reliable delivery of energy that heats their homes and powers businesses,” said National Grid New York President Matt Barnett in an emailed statement.
Climate and consumer advocates, meanwhile, were outraged.
AARP New York and the environmental law nonprofit Earthjustice said in separate statements that regulators handed National Grid a “credit card” without adequate transparency.
“It was pretty infuriating,” said Kim Fraczek, director of the climate group Sane Energy Project, after the commission vote. “This was probably a done deal before it was even filed as a proceeding.”
The Department of Public Service, which oversees utilities day to day and prepares the commission’s decisions, told New York Focus in September that it communicated with National Grid about its plan before it was filed.
On Thursday, agency staff and commissioners presented the plan as a way to cover necessary expenses without the steep rate hike National Grid was originally expected to seek last spring.
“All else being equal, we believe customers will be slightly better off in the end” under the newly approved deal, said DPS assistant counsel Brandon Goodrich.
Many watchdogs had presented a third scenario, where regulators didn’t approve any new rate plan. That would have lowered rates next spring, after the company paid off a portion of its recent spending. But Goodrich said that “was never a legitimate option.”
Fraczek said regulators were thinking too narrowly.
“If they’re looking to actually prioritize affordability, they would reduce and retire the entire gas system” and advance electric options instead, she said. National Grid plans to spend about $700 million replacing gas pipes under the approved deal.
As Albany begins its legislative session in January, her group plans to renew its push for a bill that would impose more transparency on those pipe replacements and pursue new legislation to end the requirement that utilities supply gas to any customer who wants it.
Governor Kathy Hochul painted Thursday’s decision as a win for affordability.
“The Governor has been resolute in the need to hold the line on utility rates and approving this freeze today is a step in the right direction,” said spokesperson Ken Lovett in an emailed statement.
He highlighted utility reforms passed in this year’s budget, which will put new checks on companies’ rate hike bids starting in January.
National Grid, however, is poised to file its next rate case before that, according to DPS.
The agency’s press release about Thursday’s decision said the company will file the case in December in order for new rates to take effect in April 2028, after the “freeze” expires. In a statement provided after publication, DPS spokesperson Kim Mashke said that National Grid is only filing before the new year in order to meet that April deadline, and has agreed to abide by the new restrictions.