Conservative dark-money group sues to block Colorado’s income tax overhaul from taking effect
The long-running effort by untraceable conservative “dark money” groups to defeat a Colorado progressive income tax measure shows no signs of stopping after voters approved the measure at the ballot box this month.
The right-wing nonprofit Advance Colorado and two GOP state lawmakers sued the state in Denver District Court Thursday, asking a judge to enjoin the state from “collecting any increased taxes under” the new tiered income tax system established by Amendment 87, which the lawsuit argues was adopted in violation of the Taxpayer’s Bill of Rights.
“TABOR is a citizen-initiated constitutional measure that requires proposed tax increases be presented to the people through a clear ballot question and an accurate notice so that voters are not confused or misinformed when they vote,” the suit reads. “Amendment 87 was presented to Colorado voters in a form, and with a notice, that directly conflicts with the explicit protections TABOR guarantees.”
Colorado voters narrowly approved Amendment 87 on Nov. 3, with 52% in favor and 48% opposed. The measure hikes corporate and individual income tax rates on the top 3% of earners, while the 97% of Coloradans who earn less than $500,000 per year receive a slight income tax reduction.
With all races called, Colorado voters say ‘yes’ to 7 of 14 ballot measures
Together with Proposition NN — a measure also approved by voters this year to raise the annual revenue growth cap established by TABOR — the amendment’s adoption represented the most sweeping set of changes to Colorado tax policy since voters passed TABOR in 1992.
That’s made the measure a target of a powerful, deep-pocketed network of Colorado conservative policy advocates, who sought to block it at every possible stage, including challenging it at the state’s Title Board and suing the secretary of state to remove the amendment from the ballot in a case that was decided just days before Election Day. Advance Colorado also backed a countermeasure, Proposition 136, to block the amendment by capping income tax rates at their current level, but voters rejected it.
The group said Thursday that it had filed the lawsuit on behalf of Republican state Sens. Barbara Kirkmeyer of Brighton and Byron Pelton of Sterling. The complaint alleges that Amendment 87 violated TABOR by consolidating a constitutional amendment — striking language requiring a flat income tax — with a statutory tax increase in the form of its tiered system.
“It’s clear that Amendment 87 should have been filed as two measures, not a single one,” Kirkmeyer said in a statement. “The constitution wasn’t followed, and voters will pay the price if this measure isn’t overturned.”
The complaint also alleges that the state’s 2026 voter information booklet included tables that miscalculated some of the tax changes resulting from Amendment 87, and that it misstated how the revenue raised by the measure would be used, citing recent comments from outgoing Gov. Jared Polis that the new revenue could soon be eaten up by growth in the state’s Medicaid budget.
Absent from the lawsuit, however, are any further assertions that Amendment 87’s passage has resulted in the elimination of tax deductions for Social Security income, veterans’ pensions and other forms of income — a claim that featured prominently in the opposition campaign’s messaging to voters in recent months, despite being repeatedly debunked by fact checkers.
Advance Colorado did not respond to inquiries about whether it still asserts that those deductions will be eliminated when Amendment 87 takes effect on Jan. 1.
New ballot measures
Advance Colorado on Thursday also filed four proposed ballot initiatives for the 2027 election. All are variations on a “graduated income tax” system that would reestablish a top rate of 4.4% for higher income brackets.
Two versions of the proposal would exempt all income under $100,000 from state income taxes, while the other two would exempt the first $50,000 and tax the next $50,000 at 3.71%.
“When people see the economic destruction that Amendment 87 will cause, they will want immediate reform,” Advance Colorado president Michael Fields said in a statement. “Exempting the first $100,000 of income for individuals and businesses will make Colorado more competitive and will put more money in people’s pockets.”