Auburn University Board of Trustees to vote on new post-tenure review policy
The Auburn University Board of Trustees is scheduled Friday to consider new policies for post-tenure review that a faculty group calls “a fundamental restructuring of the relationship between the university and its faculty.”
The change was authorized by a state law signed by Gov. Kay Ivey earlier this year that also authorized boards of trustees to disband faculty senates and drew protests at Auburn.
According to the board’s meeting materials, the university will use a four-category scale. The four categories are “exceeds expectations,” “meets expectations,” “does not meet expectations” and “unsatisfactory.” Under the policy, post-tenure review would occur at least once every six years. No faculty member could be reviewed more than once a year.
The policy states after the review is done, the dean of the college will make a recommendation to the provost who can “seek advice from an appropriate faculty advisory body or other peer review body before making a final performance rating determination.”
After the provost assigns a performance rating, the university president “shall exercise such review, approval, or oversight of post-tenure review determinations as provided by university procedures.”
The Auburn Chapter of the American Association of University Professors said in a statement Thursday night it “unequivocally opposes” the tenure review policy.
“This policy represents a fundamental restructuring of the relationship between the university and its faculty,” the statement said. “At its core, it concentrates unprecedented authority in administrators while diminishing the role of faculty judgment and due process.”
Under the proposed policy change, professors who receive a rating of “does not meet expectations” will be referred to the provost to determine if a “Performance Improvement Plan” will be appropriate. Tenured professors who received a rating of “unsatisfactory” and can be dismissed without havinga a Performance Improvement Plan.
Previously, the University Senate conducted the post-tenure review process. The changes were authorized by HB 580, sponsored by Rep. Troy Stubbs, R-Wetumpka and signed by Gov. Kay Ivey, in April. The law led to Auburn and Jacksonville State University abolishing their faculty senates over protests from instructors at the schools. The University of Alabama and Troy University voted to maintain theirs.
“This policy reflects a university that sees us as employees to be monitored and managed. It is what happens when trust is replaced by administrative control,” the AAUP statement said.
A petition from the United Campus Workers of Alabama, an organization that works to improve working conditions, wages and benefits for all higher education employees, exceeded its goal of 500 signatures to maintain the current post-tenure review process.