New Mexico education department proposed rules draw backlash from lawmakers, school officials
Close to 30 proposed changes to New Mexico Public Education rules governing everything from student privacy to bilingual endorsements drew backlash during a Wednesday legislative hearing from state lawmakers and school district officials over both the proposals’ substance and timing.
On Oct. 20, PED published 14 proposed changes to the state’s education code, ranging from how the department manages student data in contracts with third-party education vendors, to requirements on how school districts administer literacy assessments for all K-3 students. Public comment on the proposals ends on Friday.
Two weeks later, PED published 14 additional proposals covering state reports and data submission requirements; licensure requirements for educators seeking bilingual endorsement; and clarifications to requirements for science teachers seeking to enter New Mexico classrooms. Public comment on those proposals will end Dec. 4. A majority of the proposals will take effect next year if approved.
Both lawmakers and school district officials on Wednesday expressed concern over the number of proposals and the PED timeline during an interim Legislative Education Study Committee hearing in Santa Fe.
State Rep. Brian Baca (R-Las Lunas) said he thought the state education department was “overstepping,” particularly given the pending transition between Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham’s administration and Gov.-elect Deb Haaland, who will take office in January. “My phone is blowing up here,” Baca said. “The school district and school boards just found out about this.”
Jessica Martinez, government affairs liaison for Albuquerque Public Schools, told lawmakers that APS is concerned “regarding the volume and timing” of the proposals as they “present significant challenges for meaningful district review due to their potential fiscal, operation and governance implications for school districts.”
President of the Navajo Nation Board of Education Nadine Chatto told lawmakers that she had also just learned about the proposals that day.
“These proposed changes directly affect students, schools and education, especially Native American communities and students,” Chatto said during public comment. “Yet, tribal voices, community input and perspectives of those most impacted appear to be missing from the process.”
Sen. Shannon Pinto (D-Tohatchi) highlighted the lack of tribal consultation with PED’s proposal regarding student data privacy, which “does not address tribal sovereignty or explicitly prohibit vendors from using student data to train AI models,” according to LESC analysis. The proposal would create requirements for how PED and school districts manage student data in contracts with education vendors.
Gregory Frostad, PED executive manager of policy, finance and operation, told the committee that “there was not a formal consultation process undertaken” by PED with nations, tribes and pueblos, and added that he was unaware whether the Indian Education Act requires PED to consult them on all education rule changes. Public comment on the proposal ends Friday.
The proposal to change bilingual endorsement requirements also drew flak at the hearing. According to LESC’s analysis, the proposal — which changes the process for educators seeking bilingual licensure — may impact educators who used alternative routes, such as bilingual educators who used certain language proficiency exams, to meet endorsement requirements.
Chatto said the proposal “will have significant implications for school operations, staffing and the education of Native students.”
Source NM has a pending request for comment from PED regarding the criticisms levied during the hearing.
Stan Rounds, executive director of the New Mexico Coalition of Superintendents, urged PED to postpone the rulemaking until Haaland’s administration takes effect in January, and until after the 60-day session that runs Jan. 19 to March 20.
“I want to remind us we have 28 rules and about 34 days for us to look at all 28 and look at how they intertwine and what their impacts are,” he said.
Public Charter Schools of New Mexico Advocacy Director Jamie Gonzales echoed Rounds’ comments and also asked PED to withdraw the rules and consider the timing. “Dropping 28 rules, to be quite honest, says to the field that we don’t care about your public comment. We don’t want your thoughtful comment, and we’re not going to give you time to give it. And I think that’s problematic, and it’s certainly not something that says we put kids and families first.”