Utah legislator won’t get an intern or assigned staff after discrimination inquiry, records say
A state senator won’t have her own intern or assigned staff member after an outside investigator found a claim of discrimination against her was likely true, Utah’s Senate president wrote in a document made public Monday.
Senate President Stuart Adams also determined that Sen. Kathleen Riebe, D-Cottonwood Heights, must complete additional workplace harassment training and that her office will be moved from the fourth floor of the state Capitol to another location to “provide appropriate separation from Senate staff.”
The inquiry found Riebe’s treatment of the Senate employee who filed the complaint was likely motivated at least in part by race, national origin or ethnicity. The staffer had alleged Riebe complained the most about Senators who are women of color and reported Riebe said “it is not fair to invest money for people here illegally,” among other comments Riebe has denied making.
In a letter dated Nov. 2, Adams detailed the four corrective actions to Senate Minority Leader Luz Escamilla, but the Senate redacted that information earlier this month when it provided copies of the correspondence to a number of news outlets. Utah News Dispatch appealed the redactions through Utah’s open records law, and on Monday the Senate provided the complete letter.
Riebe has said she didn’t discriminate against anyone. She and her attorney said the investigation was biased and based on an initial human resources complaint that was politically motivated.
As for the investigator’s finding that Riebe acknowledged telling staffers she did not want gay interns “who were coming out of the closet,” Riebe maintains she’d previously expressed concern for vulnerable interns but her words were twisted to sound like bigotry.
Facing calls to resign, Sen. Kathleen Riebe says discrimination report is ‘distorted’
Riebe told the investigator the complaint was an attempt at retribution after she announced plans to run for minority leader, the report states, and after Riebe had raised concerns the staffer was working on a political campaign for another senator.
Through her attorney, she asked Senate President-elect Sen. Evan Vickers last week to allow her to weigh in and wait to impose the corrective actions.
“The Senate punished Senator Riebe first and is getting around to the facts later,” her attorney Ryan McConnell said in an email Monday. “These corrective actions rest on a report built on rumor, secondhand stories, and witnesses with a political stake in the outcome.”
McConnell noted the law firm Parsons Behle & Latimer has contributed campaign funding to Senate Minority Leader Luz Escamilla, D-Salt Lake City. Public campaign finance disclosures show the firm gave $300 in January.
He emphasized that his client “has cooperated at every step” but hadn’t seen the final report before her colleagues announced they’d voted to remove her from their caucus and called on her to resign less than an hour before polls closed on Election Day.
Though Riebe was interviewed as part of the inquiry, McConnell said under the Senate’s policy, she should have also had a chance to be heard on its findings.
“We’re hopeful leadership will put an end to this political infighting and nonsense, so the Senate can get back to doing the people’s work,” McConnell said. “Senator Riebe has been elected four times, and no caucus gets to overrule those voters.”
In granting Utah News Dispatch’s request for an unredacted copy of the letter, Senate Chief of Staff Mark Thomas noted Monday that a “third party” had previously released it publicly. The Salt Lake Tribune reported on Nov. 6 that it had obtained the full document and detailed the remedial measures.
The outside review cost the Legislature a total of $14,435, according to invoices provided to Utah News Dispatch in response to a public records request.
Riebe’s current Utah Senate term runs through Jan. 1, 2029. She’s an educator and former member of the Utah State Board of Education who has served in the Senate since 2018.