WV Supreme Court upholds admonishment of judge who spoke publicly about CPS understaffing
The West Virginia Supreme Court has decided to admonish a well-respected judge after he raised alarm bells publicly about a worrying shortage of Child Protective Services workers in his area.
Third Circuit Judge Tim Sweeney’s concerns about CPS staffing were legitimate, Supreme Court Chief Justice C. Haley Bunn wrote in a Nov. 12 opinion, but she said the judge’s actions were outside the bounds of rules governing judicial conduct.
“We readily acknowledge that Judge Sweeney has never been disciplined as a lawyer or judge despite many years of service. He was cooperative and forthright in this matter, and his misconduct was neither self-promoting nor dishonest,” Bunn wrote. “And while his motivations do not justify his actions, we find that an admonishment adequately deters similar misconduct in the future and is a proportionate sanction for Judge Sweeney’s conduct viewed in its totality.”
“That said, we have no doubt that Judge Sweeney had honorable motives and commendable concern for protection of the children in his circuit; this Court has expressed similar concern regarding understaffing,” the Chief Justice also wrote.
Last February, Sweeney ordered state health officials, including the former Human Services secretary, to report to the Ritchie County Courthouse and receive assignments as CPS workers. Sweeney said that local CPS workers were overworked and understaffed, leading to missed deadlines and treatment for children.
Sweeney contacted Ogden Newspapers reporter Steven Allen Adams about the issue, and Adams was the first to report on the order. Sweeney argued that he had an ethical duty to bring attention to the state’s CPS staffing crisis.
The judge’s contact with a reporter over the matter landed him in hot water with the West Virginia Judicial Investigation Commission. The group admonished Sweeney, saying he violated five judicial conduct rules, including releasing judicial statements on pending and impending cases and admonished him.
Sweeney objected to the commission’s admonishment, arguing that he spoke about systemic issues like CPS staffing, not confidential information about children’s cases. Human Services officials contacted Sweeney within hours of receiving the order and addressed staffing issues.
The state Supreme Court upheld the Judicial Investigation Commission’s admonishment.
Justice Bunn, writing for the court, concluded that Sweeney committed seven total violations of the state Code of Judicial Conduct.
“No part of a court’s charge to prioritize abuse and neglect proceedings includes the authority to use judicial powers and improper publicity to pressure the State to address an issue of its choosing and to its subjective satisfaction outside of a justiciable controversy,” Bunn wrote.
“While Judge Sweeney’s conduct happened to concern a matter that elicits universal agreement— the well-being of children — judges who stray so far outside their role such as to violate the Code are not immunized from discipline based on the popularity or success of their misconduct.”
Sweeney told Ogden Newspapers on Friday that he would accept his admonishment, but did not regret his actions regarding CPS understaffing.
“Sometimes you just have to take a punch for the kids,” Sweeney said. “Abused and neglected children were helped and shortcomings were addressed. That was and continues to be my goal.”
Sweeney was also admonished for social media activity not related to the CPS staffing issues. Bunn said that Sweeney’s social media, which included sharing a fundraiser repost and law enforcement hiring posts, could create “an appearance of bias.” It called Sweeney’s impartiality into question, the Chief Justice wrote.