Report: Mayo Clinic was the nation’s least charitable hospital in 2023
Mayo Clinic’s flagship Rochester hospital ranked last in the nation in how much it gave in financial assistance relative to how much it received in tax breaks in 2023, according to a new analysis from Massachusetts-based think tank The Lown Institute.
Nonprofit hospitals are required to provide charity care — financial assistance for people who can’t pay for their care — and other community health programs in exchange for their tax-exempt status, a trade that health policy experts have said is hard to monitor.
The think tank analyzed 2023 tax data for around 3,000 hospitals across the country, along with Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services hospital cost reports and local property assessments, to calculate the difference between how much hospitals received in tax breaks and how much they spent on charity care and other community investments.
The report found that Mayo Clinic’s Rochester hospital received $366 million more in tax breaks than it gave in charity care. The second worst offender in the state, HealthPartners’ Methodist Hospital in St. Louis Park, had a far smaller difference: $21 million. Minnesota hospitals altogether received $591 more in tax breaks than they gave in charity care.
Half of the country’s nonprofit hospitals received more in tax breaks than they give in charity care, according to the report.
A Mayo Clinic spokesperson disputed the findings, calling The Lown Institute’s methodology “deeply flawed.” The analysis does not count the significant investments Mayo Clinic makes as a world-renowned research institution into developing new treatments and training the next generation of physicians.
“The methodology excludes important categories of Community Benefit identified by the IRS, including Medicaid shortfall, medical research and health professions education,” the statement reads.
Mayo charged private insurance over 4 times more than Medicare for outpatient procedures in 2022
The Minnesota Attorney General’s Office began investigating Mayo Clinic in 2022 after reports in the Rochester Post Bulletin that the health system sued patients who were eligible for charity care over medical debt. The investigation found that Mayo instructed staff to avoid discussing charity care and had an overly complicated charity care application.
Mayo doubled the amount of charity care it provided from 2022 to 2024, after the investigation began.
The Lown Institute’s analysis time frame predates a settlement agreement between the attorney general and Mayo in 2025 that required the health system to use better charity care applications and provide charity care to some patients who are eligible without needing to apply.
A KFF Health News and Star Tribune joint investigation earlier this year found that Minnesota’s hospitals and health systems give less financial aid as a percentage of their operating budgets on average than hospitals in almost every other state, making them among the least charitable in the country.