Home Part of States Newsroom
News
New Mexico’s ‘insurer of last resort’ to make all enrollees reapply, director says

Share

New Mexico’s ‘insurer of last resort’ to make all enrollees reapply, director says

Nov 16, 2026 | 2:18 pm ET
By Patrick Lohmann
New Mexico’s ‘insurer of last resort’ to make all enrollees reapply, director says
Description
New Mexican homeowners who receive coverage from the Fair Access to Insurance Requirements Plan will receive notices of non-renewal sometime in 2027, the plan’s executive director announced Nov. 14, 2026, at the Rural Housing Summit in Las Vegas. (Photo by Patrick Lohmann/Source NM)

Roughly 8,000 New Mexico homeowners covered through the state’s “insurer of last resort” will receive notices next year that their policies aren’t being renewed, an official overseeing the high-risk pool announced Friday at a housing conference in Las Vegas.

Analisa Sisneros, executive director of the state’s Fair Access to Insurance Requirements Plan, told attendees at the Rural Housing Summit that the plan’s administrators are updating the plan’s software and, in doing so, will issue non-renewal notices to all homeowners who are covered through the policy. 

All policyholders will be able to reapply for the FAIR Plan, Sisneros said, but only after they try again to receive coverage in the regular insurance market. The software update presents an opportunity for a “clean slate” that will help ensure the plan is available to those who most need it for years to come, she said.

The FAIR Plan offers homeowners insurance to those who face challenges getting policies in the private market due to increasingly expensive natural disasters and other factors. While the plan is supposed to provide temporary coverage and serve as the “insurer of last resort,” Sisneros said that some FAIR plan enrollees have been on the plan since the 1990s.

All policyholders will be able to reapply for the FAIR Plan, Sisneros said, but only after they try again to receive coverage in the regular insurance market. The software update presents an opportunity for a “clean slate” that will help ensure the plan is available to those who most need it for years to come, she said.

New Mexico’s ‘insurer of last resort’ to make all enrollees reapply, director says
Analisa Sisneros, second from left, executive director of New Mexican Fair Access to Insurance Requirements Plan, announced Nov. 14, 2026, at the Rural Housing Summit in Las Vegas that homeowners who receive coverage from the Fair Access to Insurance Requirements Plan will receive notices of non-renewal sometime in 2027. (Photo by Patrick Lohmann/Source NM)

The notice of non-renewal, expected sometime next year, will “highly encourage” enrollees to seek coverage elsewhere, Sisneros said.

“But if that is not an option for you, you are more than welcome to come back to the FAIR Plan,” she said Friday. 

The FAIR Plan has seen steadily increasing enrollment in recent years, as well as scrutiny from state lawmakers concerned the plan isn’t adequate or solvent. A spike in private insurers opting not to renew policies across the state has heightened the plan’s importance. 

Homeowners in wildfire-prone counties, in particular, are increasingly turning to the FAIR Plan for coverage, state officials said recently. They’re joining homeowners in areas prone to damaging hail and high winds, such as southeast New Mexico. 

Faced with that trend, Sisneros said Friday that canceling everyone’s policies, at least temporarily, will make sure the plan remains available for those who truly need it. 

“The reimagined FAIR Plan is bringing it into the times and making sure we know what we’re ensuring and that we are not taking on business that in the long term can mess with the FAIR Plan solvency,” she said. “We want to make sure we remain around for years to come.”

Sisneros did not respond to Source NM’s phone call seeking further comment Monday. 

Rep. Anita Gonzales (D-Las Vegas), who convened the homeowners insurance panel where Sisneros made the announcement, told Source NM after the summit Friday that she expects a “lot of kickback” from policyholders who will have to submit new paperwork to apply or potentially see higher premiums as a result of the update. 

But she also said she understands the FAIR Plan administrators’ reasoning.

“I don’t think they’re necessarily trying to kick anybody off. It’s kind of like, ‘Let’s get you restarted,” she said. “This will require them to attempt to get on the market, and if they still get denied, they still have an opportunity to be on the FAIR Plan.”