Home Part of States Newsroom
News
Nearly 40% of new Idaho inmates had drug charges, state watchdog report on overcrowded prisons finds

Share

Nearly 40% of new Idaho inmates had drug charges, state watchdog report on overcrowded prisons finds

Nov 19, 2026 | 5:34 pm ET
Nearly 40% new Idaho inmates had drug charges, state watchdog report on overcrowded prisons finds
Description
There are approximately 8,000 incarcerated individuals in nine state-owned prisons and five community reentry centers across Idaho. (Photo by Mia Maldonado/Idaho Capital Sun)

In Idaho, which imprisons women at the highest rate in the nation, drug charges account for much of the state’s prison population, a new watchdog report found.

The report by the independent state agency, the Office of Performance Evaluations, highlighted why the state has the seventh-highest incarceration rate in the nation, and the highest in the Mountain West. Over the past decade, drug possession sentences account for 39% of the state’s prison growth, more than any other crime, the agency’s researchers found. 

Researchers said the drug crime data they analyzed didn’t show which drugs people were charged with being in possession of, or of trafficking. But user data they obtained from the state’s drug court system found that methamphetamine was by far the most reported, by 48% of people, with heroin and other opioids in second with 20%. 

“While women are less likely than men to be incarcerated for drug possession, they are much less likely to be incarcerated for other crimes,” the report found. “More than half of the growth of women in custody over the past two decades comes from women convicted of a single drug possession charge.”

The 88-page report delivered a slew of statistics, including:

  • Twice as many women were imprisoned in Idaho in 2025 than in 2005.
  • Women are likely in prison for drug possession, even more than other drug offenses. Over a fifth, 22%, of females in prison in Idaho had just one drug possession sentence, compared to just 10% of males in prison. 
  • Nearly two thirds, 61%, of women in prisons had drug possession sentences, compared to 35% of men in prisons.  
  • Drug possession was the least likely category of crimes to have charges amended, with just 6% of felony cases being reduced to misdemeanors or lesser charges. Researchers used 2022 data for that metric to give court cases time to close. Researchers say that statistic can be explained by drug possession laws offering less sentencing options than other crimes, and inconsistencies in access to misdemeanor probation. 

As the rest of the nation’s imprisonment rates fell amid declining crime rates, Idaho’s largely didn’t budge, the report found. The state kept incarcerating a similar share of people, even during years of peak population growth and reduced crime rates.

A bipartisan group of state lawmakers requested the study in March to help address the state’s overflowing prisons.

Four of the state’s largest counties — Ada, Canyon, Kootenai and Twin Falls — contributed the bulk, 87%, of growth in the state’s inmate population. 

When people are first charged with drug possession in Idaho, researchers say they “rarely receive a prison term,” but many enter the state’s prison system “after failing probation or retained jurisdiction,” the report said. 

Assault crimes were the fastest rising crime reported in Idaho

Sentences for some of the most serious crimes  — homicide and sex crimes — have grown, researchers found, but they are “not a large driver of incarceration.”

The fastest rising crime contributing to Idaho’s incarceration over the past decade was assault, which rose by 30%, ahead of alcohol-related crimes, at 24% growth, and drug crimes, which rose by 20%. 

A big part of that rise is domestic violence cases. A fifth of all people in prison on assault crimes were in on domestic violence, which saw the fastest growth among assault crimes. 

That could be spurred by a 2004 state law that treated any repeat domestic violence offense as a felony, and let out-of-state domestic violence charges count.

“This change made it more likely that both chronic offenders and severe offenders would be eligible for felony domestic violence charges,” the report found. 

State legislators asked for another report

But unlike many of the agency’s watchdog reports, it delivered no recommendations for policy changes. Some lawmakers wanted more answers.

House Minority Leader Ilana Rubel, D-Boise,
Idaho House Minority Leader Ilana Rubel, D-Boise, addresses reporters at a press conference on Jan. 12, 2026, at the State Capitol Building in Boise. (Photo by Pat Sutphin for the Idaho Capital Sun)

Idaho House Minority Leader Ilana Rubel, D-Boise, asked how mandatory minimums played a role in drug possession cases. The analyst behind the report, Christopher Shank, said it’s complicated.

“The majority of people that we looked at with drug offenses generally had possession charges that weren’t impacted by mandatory minimums,” he said. “The people who did have possession charges impacted by mandatory minimums, in most cases, they were sentenced for the lowest tier of mandatory minimums.”

An InvestigateWest report recently found that several users were charged with drug trafficking under a 2024 state mandatory minimum law for fentanyl. Shank said he didn’t have data on that trend himself, but said people charged with drug trafficking often plead down to a lower offense.

“It’s an open question how often people who are convicted of trafficking are holding amounts that are intended for personal use,” he said.

The legislative panel that ordered the report, the Joint Legislative Oversight Committee, on Wednesday ordered a follow-up report. 

Sen. Dave Lent, R-Idaho Falls, chats with a colleague before an Idaho Senate floor session
Sen. Dave Lent, R-Idaho Falls, chats with a colleague before an Idaho Senate floor session on March 10, 2025, at the Idaho Capitol Building in Boise. (Pat Sutphin for the Idaho Capital Sun)

Sen. Dave Lent, R-Idaho Falls, supported the motion. He pointed to Idaho’s incarceration rate being five times higher than Utah, the state’s neighbor, as evidence that “something in our process isn’t working.”

“I don’t think the women in our state are the worst in the country,” Lent said. “I really don’t. And what we’re seeing in the data is telling us that.”

In a letter sent before the report went public Wednesday, Gov. Brad Little said the Idaho Department of Correction “has consistently tracked the trends outlined in this report and continues to work closely with law enforcement, the judiciary, and other partners to develop timely and responsible outcomes.”

“Idaho continues to be one of the safest places in the nation to live, work, and raise a family,” the governor wrote. “Our quality of life reflects our strong investments in public safety. Public safety requires a criminal justice system that is tough on crime while ensuring those who want to become productive members of society have the adequate tools to do so.”