KY judge calls misconduct allegations ‘politically motivated’
A Kentucky judge facing allegations of misconduct has asked a state panel to dismiss the charges, arguing in part that the prosecution is politically motivated as he awaits confirmation as a federal judge.
Circuit Judge Dan Ballou said in a response to the charges that the matter is “an improper selective prosecution” and is “improperly motivated by political and free speech affiliations.”
Ballou did not specify those affiliations. However, he has long been close to Republican U.S. Sen. Rand Paul.
Ballou publicly supported Paul in his initial 2010 Senate race – drawing a reprimand from the state Judicial Conduct Commission given that Ballou was a judge at the time – and Paul endorsed Ballou when he ran unsuccessfully for state Supreme Court.
When President Donald Trump nominated Ballou to be a federal judge in August, Paul called Ballou, a U.S. Marine veteran and longtime state judge, a “Great American.”
Ballou has not yet been confirmed to a federal judgeship in Kentucky by the full U.S. Senate, though a committee forwarded his nomination this month.
Laura Hendrix, executive secretary of the commission, said the agency could not comment on the claim that the prosecution is politically motivated.
Dispute with attorney
The misconduct allegations against Ballou come against the backdrop of his federal nomination.
The Kentucky Judicial Conduct Commission (JCC) notified Ballou in late October of formal charges that he committed misconduct.
The charges arose from an interaction Ballou had with a lawyer in his court. He is a circuit judge for McCreary and Whitley counties.
The lawyer, Kerri Bartley, had filmed a video in the courthouse in McCreary County in late August with a caption that said, “How I feel when I’m trapped in a musty courtroom surrounded by pictures of the old yt (white) male judges knowing the current old yt (white) male judge is going to disagree with everything I say.”
The video showed Bartley’s face with portraits of former judges in the background, according to the JCC complaint.
Bartley had a case before Ballou that day, according to the record.
Bartley posted the video on social media.
Ballou’s staff told him about the video, and he directed Bartley to appear before him.
At that appearance, Bartley apologized, called her behavior thoughtless and said she intended no disrespect.
Ballou allegedly interrupted her to ask if she was aware of any other judges allowing attorneys to make videos in the courtroom, then interrupted her again when she began responding.
Ballou asked Bartley where she attended law school and told her she “might want to look into a refund if (she) didn’t learn any better than to come into a courtroom and make videos,” according to the JCC charges.
Before Bartley could respond, Ballou told the bailiff to hand her an order he had prepared and dismissed her from the courtroom, rolling his eyes, according to the charges.
According to the complaint, Ballou drafted an order before Bartley’s appearance that alleged she had “for some bizarre and inexplicable reason chose to make a childish, unprofessional, disrespectful, belligerent, immature, and extraordinarily arrogant video.”
The order barred Bartley from using or possessing any electronic device in the McCreary County Courthouse and the Whitley County Judicial Center, and directed that the notice be distributed to more than a dozen local officials and the Kentucky Bar Association.
The JCC said Ballou decided on disciplinary measures for Bartley before she even appeared and did not give her a chance to respond.
The order also used language about Bartley indicating a possible bias, “including a statement regarding the courtroom being turned into ” ‘Romper Room,’ ” the conduct commission said.
The commission alleged that Ballou violated a number of ethics rules.
Those included rules requiring judges to perform all duties fairly and impartially; prohibiting judges from manifesting bias or prejudice, or engaging in harassment by words or conduct while doing their judicial duties; requiring judges to accord to every person who has a legal interest in a proceeding, or that person’s lawyer, the right to be heard; and requiring judges to be patient, dignified, and courteous to lawyers and others with whom the judge deals in an official capacity.
In his response filed Nov. 9, Ballou denied engaging in any misconduct and said he had not pre-judged discipline for Bartley before she appeared.
Bartley violated prior orders barring the use of cell phones in the court, according to Ballou’s response, though the JCC charges noted that some other attorneys had their phones out during her court appearance.
Ballou raised more than a dozen defenses altogether, including that his handling of the issue was within his duty to maintain order and decorum in the court; that his decisions were in good faith; that the charges infringe on the independence of the judiciary; that the JCC violated confidentiality rules; and that the charges violate his free-speech rights.
Ballou also argued in his response that the process the JCC uses, in which the panel both issues accusations and then decides on them, violates his constitutional right to due process.
Ballou said in his response that the commission has proposed issuing a public reprimand for him, which he argued is inappropriate and excessive.
Ballou asked in his response for the charges to be dismissed.
One of Ballou’s attorneys, John G. Prather Jr., of Somerset, said the JCC did not adequately investigate the allegations against Ballou.
“It’s certainly nothing to raise an issue like this,” Prather said of Ballou’s handling of the issue.
Attorneys Howard Mann of Corbin and Christopher Wiest of Covington also represent Ballou.
The next formal step in the case would be to schedule a hearing before the conduct commission.
Ballou is among several conservative nominees to federal judgeships the Trump Administration hopes to push through before Democrats take over the U.S. Senate in January.
If confirmed Ballou would replace former U.S. District Judge Gregory F. Van Tatenhove, who left the bench to head the law school at the University of Kentucky.