Garten sworn in as Indiana Senate leader after court intervention, calls for recount of own election
Hours after winning a court battle that allowed him to take office, Republican state Sen. Chris Garten was officially chosen as the Indiana Senate’s new leader Tuesday and announced plans to seek a recount of his own race.
Garten, whose reported 297-vote victory over Democratic challenger Nick Marshall remains disputed, was elected Senate president pro tem without opposition from either party after the Indiana Supreme Court unanimously lifted a judge’s order blocking him from being sworn in.
But the legal fight over his reelection isn’t done yet.
Speaking to reporters in the Senate chamber after his swearing-in, Garten accused Democrats of attempting to use the courts to prevent him from taking office, calling the effort “lawfare” and arguing that it threatened the constitutional rights of voters in his southern Indiana district.
“What we witnessed was an extraordinary attempt to use the judicial system to prevent the people of an entire Senate district from having their elected representative take office,” Garten said. “Let me be very clear: this is much bigger than Chris Garten. This is bigger than Republicans, and it’s bigger than Democrats. This is about the Constitution. This is about the rule of law, and this is about the fundamental right of Hoosiers to choose who represents them.”
Garten said he had directed his attorneys to file a petition for an official recount, despite maintaining confidence in his narrow victory.
“As the candidate who’s the reported victor that’s being challenged, I am voluntarily requesting that the votes be recounted,” he said. “I’m taking this action because I believe election integrity is too important to become a political talking point, unlike my Democrat counterparts. Every lawful vote deserves to be counted accurately.”
He did not take questions from reporters after his remarks.
Court fight over close election
The five Indiana Supreme Court justices ruled unanimously in Garten’s favor Tuesday, just hours after his attorneys filed an emergency appeal of a temporary restraining order issued Monday by Scott County Circuit Court Judge Jason Mount.
Mount’s order had prohibited Garten from “presenting himself to take the oath of office as, or to be seated as, the Senator from District 45.”
Garten’s attorneys argued that Mount exceeded his authority because the Indiana Constitution gives each chamber of the Legislature exclusive authority to determine the elections, qualifications and returns of its members.
The Supreme Court agreed, citing the constitutional provision that “the respective houses of the legislature are the sole judges of the results of the elections of their members.”
The justices left intact other portions of Mount’s order preventing the Clark County Election Board from certifying the county’s vote totals.
Judge issues order blocking Indiana Senate GOP leader Chris Garten from starting new term
The legal dispute stems from voting equipment problems on Election Day at Jeffersonville High School, where four precincts voted and a ballot scanner malfunction was reported.
Democrats have maintained that the Clark County Election Board, which has a 2-1 Republican majority, failed to adequately investigate the problems before moving forward with the election results.
The reported totals for Senate District 45, which includes all of Clark County and part of Floyd County, show Garten ahead of Marshall by 297 votes, or about two-thirds of a percentage point.
Democrats argued that Garten should not be sworn in for another four-year term before the Indiana Recount Commission has an opportunity to review the election.
Garten’s attorneys countered that state law already establishes a recount and election contest process for resolving such disputes.
“A recount and contest before the Recount Commission is the remedy the General Assembly created for the claims Petitioner raises,” they argued in court filings.
Garten was represented by prominent conservative attorney James Bopp, along with Ted Nolting and Philip Lashutka of the Indianapolis firm Kroger, Gardis and Regas.
Mount, a Democrat, was assigned to the case after a Clark County judge recused himself. He is the brother of Republican U.S. Rep. Erin Houchin, who previously served in the Indiana Senate alongside Garten.
Candidates have until Tuesday to file recount petitions, while county party chairs have until Friday. State law requires the Indiana Recount Commission to complete legislative recounts by Dec. 20, unless the deadline is extended for good cause.
Garten takes Senate leadership
Despite the uncertainties surrounding his election, Garten’s elevation to Senate leadership proceeded smoothly Tuesday afternoon.
After taking the oath of office for his new four-year term, Garten was nominated for president pro tem by Sen. Eric Koch. No other nominations were offered, and senators approved his election by voice vote without any audible opposition.
Indiana Chief Justice Loretta Rush administered the leadership oath as Koch held the Bible.
Garten then shook hands and briefly embraced outgoing Senate President Pro Tem Rodric Bray, who received a standing ovation from senators during Garten’s subsequent remarks.
The proceedings were briefly interrupted earlier in the afternoon when a Senate doorman collapsed in the chamber, prompting an emergency recess while medical personnel attended to him. He was conscious when he was transported to the hospital.
Let me be very clear: this is much bigger than Chris Garten. This is bigger than Republicans, and it's bigger than Democrats. This is about the Constitution. This is about the rule of law, and this is about the fundamental right of Hoosiers to choose who represents them.
The leadership transition for the Republican-controlled chamber comes ahead of the 2027 legislative session, when lawmakers will be responsible for adopting Indiana’s next two-year state budget.
In his first address as president pro tem, Garten described his rough childhood before he was adopted.
“Only in America could a kid who grew up with child abuse, drug abuse, domestic violence, who relied on food, stamps, and welfare, and was ultimately blessed with an opportunity to be adopted one day, stand before you as president pro tem of Indiana State Senate,” he said. “That’s the promise of America, and it’s a promise worth protecting for every Hoosier, regardless of where they started life.”
Garten also pledged to emphasize affordability, tax relief, education, childcare, government accountability, Medicaid sustainability and public safety.
He called for respectful debate between Republicans and Democrats and said senators should be able to disagree without allowing political differences to interfere with their work.
“Disagreement is inevitable,” Garten said. “Dysfunction is a choice.”
Garten calls for recount
Garten’s subsequent remarks to reporters struck a sharper tone.
He criticized the legal challenge brought by Democrats, arguing that it went beyond an ordinary election dispute and risked leaving his constituents without representation.
“In my view, these actions created unnecessary election chaos and brought Indiana to the brink of a constitutional confrontation over a disputed election,” he said.
Garten added that he respected the judicial system and separation of powers, but he maintained that the restraining order raised serious questions about the authority of courts to intervene in legislative elections.
He also said the recount he intends to seek would provide an opportunity to independently verify the election results.
“I’m not asking anyone to simply take my word for the outcome. I’m asking the ballots to speak for themselves, and whenever lawful review is conducted, I expect it to be thorough, transparent, and consistent with the law,” Garten said. “Election integrity should never depend on which candidate wins, and neither should our commitment to the rule of law.”
Senate Democratic Leader Shelli Yoder, who was reelected to her leadership position, declined to engage with Garten’s accusation that Democrats were using the courts for political purposes.
“Honestly, I think Hoosiers really want us to stay focused on the task at hand, and that is what the Senate Democrats are going to be focused on — lowering the cost of living, protecting the services that they need, as well as holding government accountable to remain transparent — so they know where every tax dollar is going,” Yoder told reporters.
Asked about Garten’s decision to seek a recount, Yoder said he was entitled to pursue that process.
“He has every right to. I think it’s important that if there is concern with those living in Clark County, Clark County is doing what they need to do, and if he wants to see that, he absolutely can exercise his right to do so,” she said.
The Senate also adopted changes to its rules Tuesday, including separate committees for K-12 and higher education and revised bill-filing limits and deadlines.
The chamber recessed rather than adjourned. Senate Republican staff said senators would return Dec. 19 for administrative matters.
The regular legislative session begins in January.