Home Part of States Newsroom
Brief
ACLU-WV opposes attorney general’s motion to dismiss school funding lawsuit

Share

ACLU-WV opposes attorney general’s motion to dismiss school funding lawsuit

Nov 20, 2026 | 1:58 pm ET
By Lori Kersey
ACLU-WV opposes attorney general’s motion to dismiss school funding lawsuit
Description
The American Civil Liberties Union of West Virginia opposes a motion by the state Attorney General Office to dismiss a case on the state’s school funding formula. (Photo by Alexander Castro/Rhode Island Current)

Attorneys representing a Lincoln County student in a legal challenge over the state’s school funding formula have opposed a motion by the state Attorney General Office to dismiss the case. 

The attorney general’s argument in a motion last week should leave the Supreme Court and the state “deeply concerned,” the attorneys with the American Civil Liberties Union of West Virginia wrote in a response filed Thursday.  

“To avoid enforcement of one of West Virginia’s most firmly established rights, the State Officer Respondents propound a thoroughly undemocratic portrait of state government,” the attorneys wrote. “If the arguments of the State Officer Respondents prevail, the Legislature will have held itself to be the final arbiter of our Constitution, then used that self-proclaimed authority to  insulate itself from judicial review.”

They asked that the attorney general’s motion be denied. 

“The West Virginia Constitution, Not the Legislature, Defines This Court’s Jurisdiction,” they wrote in a 19-page filing. “The Constitution is the supreme law of West Virginia, and every branch of government is bound by it.”

ACLU-WV is representing M.D. and the student’s parent, Lakin Patten, in the legal challenge before the Supreme Court. It attempts to require state lawmakers to “correct the school funding formula.” 

Attorney General JB McCuskey — on behalf of the state officer respondents in the case — last week moved to dismiss a lawsuit, arguing that the state Supreme Court does not have authority over Senate President Randy Smith and House Speaker Roger Hanshaw, the two lawmakers named in the suit. It also argued the petitioner, a sixth grade student in Lincoln County, has not met the burden of showing standing to sue anyone.

The lawsuit lists as defendants Hanshaw, R-Clay; Smith, R-Preston; Auditor Mark Hunt; Tax Commissioner Matthew Irby; Treasurer Larry Pack; the state Department of Education; the state Board of Education, the School Building Authority, State School Superintendent Michelle Blatt, as as well as Lincoln County school board officials and county officials.

West Virginia public schools’ poor finances have prompted a wave of school closures across the state. The West Virginia Department of Education says it will take a $410 million increase in state aid for public schools to meet needs in special education, enrollment stabilization, personnel and more. 

State officials have asked the court to pause the case until April, giving lawmakers time to address the funding formula during the upcoming legislative session, when the formula is expected to be a focus. 

State school officials have agreed with the motion to delay the case. 

Attorneys with the ACLU, on behalf of M.D., have argued against delaying the case.