Fort Martin gas plant could have hidden costs for West Virginians
The recently approved Fort Martin gas plant could lead to larger power bill increases for West Virginians if data center construction doesn’t materialize.
The West Virginia Public Service Commission announced this week that initial surcharges — additional cost tacked onto electric bills to pay for infrastructure like plants and power lines — would be $1.18 a month for homeowners and renters in the Mon Power/Potomac Edison territory.
But if anticipated data centers don’t come to pay for the $2.48 billion Fort Martin gas plant in Maidsville, West Virginia, those charges could reach up to $25 a month by 2033. The plant could cost customers an anticipated total of $508 before electricity starts churning out in 2031.
Lisa Chamberlain, a spokesperson for Mon Power’s parent company First Energy, said the company doesn’t anticipate that happening because a “large load customer” — namely a data center as described in the PSC filings — is very close to inking a deal and taking on the costs.
“In all reality, the existing customers will not pay anything,” she said.
Chamberlain also noted that the surcharge will be reviewed on a six-month basis and works similar to a home construction loan — customers will only pay for what’s been spent. Even if the large load customer doesn’t sign prior to the first filing for a surcharge in January 2027, Chamberlain said residential customers will be made whole.
“If they pay for three months, they will be made whole,” she said.
Emmett Pepper, policy director for Energy Efficient West Virginia, said there’s no doubt that a high use customer like a data center would offset the cost for construction. But he’s skeptical if the pay back arrangement could work that way.
“There is no state law that requires data centers to pay back ratepayers in the way FirstEnergy was describing,” Pepper said.
The PSC, in its order approving the projects, recognized the danger that residential customers could be on the hook for the costs. But it also noted that Mon Power/Potomac Edison anticipates avoiding this through the data centers.
“The Commission will hold the Companies to that commitment,” the commission wrote,“We will not, however, prescribe a fixed and static requirement on how that is accomplished.”
The project has also raised other concerns. On Thursday, the United Mine Workers of America sent out a statement questioning if the existing coal fired Fort Martin Plant will still be used or idled once the gas plant is up and running.
“The governor and political leaders love to talk up West Virginia coal when the cameras are rolling, but then they go behind closed doors to fast track and subsidize data centers and utility projects that wipe out mining jobs, gut county schools and ship profits out of state,” said Brian Sanson, president of the United Mine Workers of America.