Home Part of States Newsroom
Commentary
Thurmond’s real fight is over money, not demolition

Share

Thurmond’s real fight is over money, not demolition

Nov 20, 2026 | 5:55 am ET
By Andrew Donaldson
Thurmond’s real fight is over money, not demolition
Description
The commercial district was where the majority of businesses operated in Thurmond, West Virginia. (Photo by Louise McLaughlin/National Park Service)

Most marriages fail over fights involving money. While not the most common daily fight, arguments over money last longer, cause more damage, and become one of the leading indicators or relationship discord.

The arranged marriage between the National Park Service and the residents of Fayette County, West Virginia still has plenty of issues to work out. While “preservation” is the topic at hand between the feds and locals, money is the issue. Since there will be no divorce between the NPS and local residents of the New River Gorge National Park and Preserve and surrounding area, finding a way to make this relationship work is the only alternative to perpetual drama. And since the federal government is going to win just about every argument when it comes down to it, constant fighting is going to limit what little say local residents have. 

Case in point, and suddenly on the radar of influencers and social media accounts, is the current situation in Thurmond, West Virginia. Especially the train station and downtown store fronts of Commercial Row that have graced pictures, films and visitors for over a century. Part of the National Park Service since the New River Gorge was declared a National River, and now National Park and Preserve, Thurmond is mostly owned by the NPS. Two things happen in parallel when the federal government owns places like Thurmond: Nobody can do anything to preserve anything without the government’s say so and permission, and the government can only preserve what it has funding to preserve. 

Words like “preservation” and “historical” make lovely nomenclature, but are not magic spells. 

Back in 2009, funding was set aside and some restoration and preservation work was done in Thurmond. By 2022, the intervening years of wear and tear combined with some good, old-fashioned vandalism was really starting to show again. What any property manager, historic preservation folks, or anyone who has ever tried to maintain any kind of property knows was self-evident in Thurmond. Occupy and use is the most effective method of preserving a structure; if it isn’t used and occupied, time and nature is most effective in destroying it. The NPS suggested demolishing some of the outlying and more decayed structures so they could focus resources on and maintain the core of Thurmond — Commercial Row, and certain other structures. Locals pushed back, and the demolitions were pushed back.

The current cycle of decay, fund, restore, repeat involves a large splash of federal cash from the Great American Outdoors Act. The NPS has put out a detailed plan wanting to fix up Commercial Row “to preserve historic homes, modernize water and wastewater systems, and improve site features throughout the district.” Part of the plan is still the demolition of some structures, but quite a few have been given a reprieve, for now. 

Notable among the structures off the demo list is the Dun Glen Ark. The two story wooden structure that looks exactly like what it is called sits roughly on the site of the infamous Dunglen Hotel. Before a 1930 fire that burned it to ground and the ensuing years where the two word name of the place became one, the hotel had 100 rooms, a 24/7 bar and gambling hall and notorious stories of various partying and debauchery since it was across the river from dry and respectable Thurmond. The only partying the Ark sees these days is the recreational kind by rafters and boaters using the adjacent river, and by generations of area youths who know a good meet up, hook up and party up spot when they need one.

The NPS version of sparing the Dun Glen structures is offering leases for use. The ark is safe, but the boat rack and other structures are “lease or destroy.” There are still other structures in the area under NPS ownership slated for demolition. The locals are not happy. There are meetings, protests, social media posts, influencer involvement and threats of legal action. Screaming headlines like this one from Yahoo, “US National Park Bulldozes Historic Town Despite Local Protests,” are pretty misleading. While some of the structures in Thurmond proper are being removed, the part of Thurmond most people picture-and most pictures of Thurmond depict-Commercial Row is what will be restored with the refocused resources. 

While residents and everyone else have a right to voice their opinions as they see fit, the kerfuffle over the demolitions and attempts to stop them are the wrong fight to have if you are truly interested in the long term preservation of Thurmond and the New River Gorge. It costs nothing to show up on social media and meetings after the heavy equipment is allocated to get to work. It costs money, resources, and constant attention to maintain these structures in the years between outrages and funding pushes. 

Despite the rhetoric, both sides of the preservation fight have valid points. Locals who complain that it was the NPS who let the structures slated for demolition fall into disrepair in the first place aren’t wrong. The NPS pointing out funding is finite and focusing on the big ticket, Instagram ready parts of attractions like Thurmond and the water, retaining walls, and upgrades needed to please the increasing crowds of park visitors must be the priority are not wrong either. Plus, the NPS operating budget has faced flat budgeting and personnel cuts for the actual running of things separate from special legislation like the GAOA funding. 

Even the loudest voices against demolition should concede not every building everywhere can be a museum. The leasing program will give one argument or the other a strong data point: if there really is a need and want to preserve and use these structures, the application process is there ready and waiting. We will see if any of the loud voices online who demand usage put their names to paper and start using. 

Even with the more than $30 million in improvements, time is undefeated and at some point those improvements will need to be renovated again. Preservation and historic are too often used as magic words that folks think will mean whatever they are applied to stays that way forever. But preservation costs money. Places on the demolition lists like the Prince Brothers store 20 miles from Thurmond in Prince, West Virginia will pass into history. Commercial Row in Thurmond will be retained. The difference for good, bad or indifference is money. And twenty years from now, the metric of was it worth it to preserve it will be answered in attendance, operational budgets, lease agreements and funding for continued preservation. Money will tell the truth of the thing. The NPS and local resident relationship will greatly depend on how everyone handles not only this allocation of funding but the management between now and the next funding crisis. Marriages, arranged or otherwise, aren’t easy …or cheap.