Home Part of States Newsroom
News
Civil rights complaint filed against Cheboygan County officials over Islamophobic posts

Share

Civil rights complaint filed against Cheboygan County officials over Islamophobic posts

Nov 19, 2026 | 2:59 pm ET
Civil rights complaint filed against Cheboygan County officials over Islamophobic posts
Description
Michigan Department of Civil Rights office in Lansing. July 23, 2026 | Photo by Jon King/Michigan Advance

A Cheboygan County planning commissioner’s recent social media post, which called anyone who voted for a Muslim in the Nov. 3 election a “treasonous traitor,” has been referred to state civil rights officials and criticized as Islamophobic by the head of a prominent Muslim civil rights organization in Michigan.

At least two complaints have been filed over the Nov. 5 Facebook post from Cheboygan County Planning Commissioner John Studer, which quoted another post from a community group unaffiliated with the county. The post was also liked by Cheboygan County Commissioner Tom Eustice, who shared a separate video of fitness influencer Jillian Michaels criticizing U.S. Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed and then offering an extremist interpretation of Sharia law.

Studer responded to Eustice’s repost of Michaels’ video by saying, “So many are clueless!! This is a battle older than we can comprehend.”

On Nov. 16, almost two weeks after El-Sayed’s election and following the post by Studer, a county resident filed a complaint that was sent to both the Cheboygan County administrator’s office and the Michigan Department of Civil Rights.

“As you know, there is no religious test for public office under the United States Constitution,” the complaint said. “It is also unconstitutional, under the United States Constitution and the Constitution of Michigan, to discriminate against someone on the basis of race, ethnicity, or religion. I demand a full and independent investigation.”

The complaint said that should the investigation determine that Studer made the post and that Eustice liked it, the full county Board of Commissioners should, at a minimum, censure Eustice and remove Studer from his appointed position as a planning commissioner.

“This cannot and must not be tolerated by Cheboygan County,” the complaint added.

Email and social media messages seeking comment from Studer and Eustice were not returned at the time of publication. Comments from either Studer or Eustice will be added to this article once they are received.

What is Sharia law, and why is it so controversial in the United States?

Tessa Roy, the public information officer for the Michigan Department of Civil Rights, confirmed for Michigan Advance that they had received the email complaint and that the department is evaluating the allegation, “as we would in any other similar situation.”

“Since this matter is pending, we cannot comment on it any further,” Roy told the Advance.

Cheboygan County Administrator Jeff Lawson, in an email to the Advance, also acknowledged the receipt of the complaint, but said there may be little that it can do officially because the comments were made on Studer’s and Eustice’s personal social media pages.

“Cheboygan County takes any complaint alleging discrimination including, but not limited to, religious discrimination very seriously,” Lawson said, adding that the alleged statements in question were made on the individuals’ personal social media account, “outside of any official municipal meeting, event, activity, or communication.”

Lawson added members of municipal boards and commissions, “like all individuals, retain the right to express personal opinions in their private capacity.”

“Individuals’ personal statements do not necessarily reflect the views, policies, opinions or positions of Cheboygan County,” Lawson wrote. “Cheboygan County is committed to treating all individuals equally and with dignity and respect, regardless of their religious beliefs, ethnicity, national origin or affiliations. Cheboygan County firmly rejects all forms of discrimination including religious discrimination or intolerance.”

Studer is a member of the Michigan Republican Party’s 1st Congressional District executive committee, and also ran for county sheriff in 2024. He serves on the county’s planning and zoning board, as well as the county Soil Conservation District Board.

Several posts on Studer’s personal Facebook page contain anti-Muslim sentiments, along with criticisms of El-Sayed and other Muslim officials, including New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani, that are focused on their religion.

El-Sayed will become the nation’s first Muslim member of the U.S. Senate when he is sworn into office early next year. He was the most prominent Muslim candidate on the statewide Michigan ballot.

Dawud Walid, director of the Michigan chapter of the Council on American-Islamic Relations, the nation’s largest Muslim civil rights and advocacy organization, has also called for an inquiry “into the bigoted post and the sharing of it by one of its planning commissioners, as well as one of its own members.”

“Government officials, who were elected to serve residents and visitors irrespective of religious affiliation, should not be impugned as traitors for voting for fellow Americans that are Muslims,” Walid said in a statement.

Meanwhile, CAIR-MI said it was also contacted by a concerned Cheboygan County resident, who is not Muslim, regarding the comment. Although a majority of Cheboygan County voters chose former Republican nominee Mike Rogers over El-Sayed, CAIR-MI did note that more than 2,300 county residents cast ballots for El-Sayed.

El-Sayed defeated Rogers statewide by seven percentage points.

While his election was historically significant, Walid said that there has been an increased amount of fearmongering and vitriol against Michigan’s Muslim population “due to millions of dollars recently poured into advertisements attempting to defeat Senator-elect El-Sayed in the 2026 midterm election.”

CAIR’s latest civil rights report also documented more than 8,600 instances of anti-Muslim bias complaints last year, which was the highest number recorded of such incidents since CAIR began publishing its civil rights report in 1996.