NJ Supreme Court weighs jail credits for time on home confinement
New Jersey’s Supreme Court will determine whether time a Hudson County man spent on home confinement with an ankle monitor under the supervision of the county’s Department of Corrections should count as time served against his sentence for aggravated assault.
The high court on Tuesday took oral arguments in Jason Edwards’ appeal, which seeks 246 days in jail credits for time he spent in the Hudson County Department of Corrections’ home confinement program that lower courts ruled should be denied because he was not physically in jail for that time.
“The problem with the state’s argument is that Mr. Edwards was never released from the custody of the Department of Corrections despite the order releasing him on pretrial monitoring,” said Assistant Deputy Public Defender Alyssa Aiello, who represented Edwards.
The dispute centers around a court rule that states defendants must get credit for time served for any time spent in custody of a jail or state hospital between the time of their arrest and sentence.
The county operated a home confinement program but it was not meant to serve individuals the court ordered released pretrial but was for the county jail’s inmates, she said.
Edwards in briefs argued he was in the department’s custody even while outside the county’s correctional facility, noting his name appeared on a daily population list and that others on Hudson’s GPS home confinement program had been arrested without warrant and returned to jail without a hearing when the department determined they’d violated the conditions of their house arrest.
The latter point, especially, distinguished the county’s home confinement program from the court’s own because the court’s system guaranteed those on home confinement greater due process, including a hearing for a bench warrant, Aiello said.
Attorneys for county and state prosecutors said there was no guarantee that would be the case because Edwards committed no violations while under electronic monitoring and so never tested the issue.
They added jail officials previously contacted him to see if he had committed a bonafide violation when he stepped out onto his porch rather than immediately remand him back to the Hudson County Correctional Facility.
In the case of an actual violation, he would still get due process after being remanded, said Assistant Hudson County Prosecutor Colleen Signorelli.
“At that point, the state would have considered moving to revoke, there would be a violation of monitoring hearing,” she said. “If no motion to revoke was filed, the court would not be able to detain him.”
In briefs, Edwards’ attorneys said jail officials warned he could be returned to jail if he did not immediately go inside of the home when he went out onto his porch to smoke.
An agreement between Edwards and the county’s Department of Corrections said any violations “shall result” in Edwards being returned to the department plus appropriate sanctions.
The justices spent much of their focus on whether Edwards’ home confinement was equivalent to jail time in the eyes of the court rule that governs jail credits.
“At home, the defendant has the ability to choose when to go to sleep, when to wake up, what to eat, when to eat, who they can visit with and when the guests may arrive — those are differences from confinement within a jail,” Chief Justice Stuart Rabner said.
Prosecutors cited those and similar differences — like the monitoring of telephonic and electronic communications of inmates — to argue Edwards shouldn’t get the credit because jail places far more restrictions on a person’s privacy and liberty than home confinement.
Aiello argued house arrest amounted to custodial confinement in Edwards’ case because while home confinement might be more comfortable than confinement in a correctional facility, he was not free to leave in either case, including because he could be charged with escape for doing so.
“I think because it’s hard for us to understand how being at home should be treated as the same as being in jail, that we often lose sight of what an extraordinary deprivation of liberty it is to be confined 24/7,” she said.
The record is silent on whether Edwards was ever told he could be charged with escape for leaving his home while confined there, but prosecutors argued house arrest pretrial could never satisfy that charge.
“You have to be in official detention to be prosecuted for escape, but the definition of official detention specifically excludes constraint incident to release on bail,” Signorelli said. “Because electronic monitoring was a condition of the defendant’s release, he was not in official detention and therefore could not be prosecuted for escape.”