Home Part of States Newsroom
Commentary
The reality TV approach to governing comes crashing down 

Share

The reality TV approach to governing comes crashing down 

Nov 17, 2026 | 4:00 am ET
By Ruth Conniff
The reality TV approach to governing comes crashing down 
Description
Sean Duffy, a member of Congress at the time, and President Donald Trump in a photo taken and posted on Instagram during Trump's first term. (Photo from Sean Duffy's Congressional Instagram account)

Reality TV star, U.S. Transportation Secretary and former Wisconsin Congressman Sean Duffy didn’t have many words of comfort to offer the 1.5 million air travelers stranded in airports across the country Friday — or to anyone in the U.S. planning to fly on an airplane any time soon. 

The system failure that led to the grounding of every flight nationwide for only the third time in modern history was entirely the fault of previous administrations, Duffy declared, speaking at a hastily organized Friday night press conference watched by beleaguered passengers sitting on the carpet at closed airport gates from coast to coast.  

“What we have is an incredibly old air traffic control system,” he explained. He made no apologies and would not promise that another massive grounding won’t happen again. Instead, he demanded that Americans everywhere pick up their phones and call their members of Congress to demand he be given another $50 billion on top of the $12.5 billion the FAA already received in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act — most of which, according to members of the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee, remains unspent. 

Duffy was vague about the details of how he will spend the additional money. But he was full of praise for President Donald Trump (the “greatest president in history”) whom he credited with leading a wildly successful effort to improve the nation’s air traffic system. The encomiums had to sound a little weird to grounded passengers at U.S. airports. “We are moving at a speed that has never been seen before,”  Duffy said of FAA upgrades. He took pains, over and over, to state that it was the old system, not the upgrades, that failed on Friday.

Then Markwayne Mullin, mixed martial arts champ and Department of Homeland Security secretary, who stood beside Duffy at the press conference wearing a hangdog expression, let the cat out of the bag:

“As Secretary Duffy of the FAA was going in and putting patches into the system, they were putting new equipment and new technology, and that new equipment and new technology — it was overwhelming the older system,” Mullin said, before an agitated Duffy practically shoved him away from the mic.

“It’s the old hardware that went down,” Duffy insisted. 

But, as Mullin clarified, that doesn’t mean the problem wasn’t caused by poorly executed upgrades to a new system.

In September, the Government Accountability Office put out a report criticizing the FAA’s rapid modernization rollout and warning about the agency’s lack of coordination, budgeting and planning: “FAA has not developed an integrated master schedule for phase 1,” of the upgrade project, the GAO found. “Instead, FAA has 11,389 individual project schedules that are not integrated. As a result, individual projects are scheduled for installations at the same sites, generally without optimizing the schedules to reduce impacts to controller operations.”

In other words, what Markwayne said.

There will be plenty of investigation that will shed more light on Duffy’s management of the FAA, and the massive system failure that occurred there on his watch. 

The reality TV approach to governing comes crashing down 
Michael Alfonso headshot courtesy of campaign

Of particular interest in Wisconsin is the role of Air Space Intelligence, the company responsible for a new AI rollout at FAA, and a contributor to Duffy’s son-in-law’s congressional campaign in Wisconsin’s 7th Congressional District. 

FEC filings show that Air Space Intelligence donated $2,500 to newly elected U.S. Rep. Michael Alfonso’s campaign on March 31, 2026. Alfonso, 26, the youngest member of Congress, who arrives with the lightest of resumes, won in part thanks to his father-in-law’s efforts landing a primary endorsement from “the greatest president in history.” Alfonso will hold the same 7th District seat previously occupied by Duffy himself. The AI company that contributed to his campaign in March received a lucrative award in June from the FAA — a no-bid $875 million, 12-year federal contract to design the new Strategic Management of Airspace, Routes and Trajectories (SMART) system that rolled out across the country on Tuesday, Nov. 10 — and became a target of increased public concern after the nationwide grounding of air traffic on Friday, Nov. 13. 

Duffy strongly denies that the AI system was related in any way to the data glitch that led to the mass grounding of flights. 

That may prove true. But a lot of air traffic controllers are disputing Duffy’s explanation for the failure. And, as is the case with so many Trump administration officials, his own conflicts make it impossible to take Duffy at his word. Following Trump’s lead, Duffy is trying to acquire an ownership interest in Air Space Intelligence for the FAA, POLITICO reports, “a striking departure for the federal government.”

The whole reality TV approach to governing is a striking departure from the public interest. Nothing brought that home quite like Duffy’s preening press conference after Friday’s flight disaster. He had nothing to offer travelers to make things better or reassure people he will keep them safe, but he did apologize for wearing jeans — after previously scolding American air travelers for not dressing up. Superficial appearances are everything in reality TV world, along with enriching yourself. Both Duffy and Alfonso — who made a star turn in his father-in-law’s recent road trip reality TV series and whose obsessively groomed look is more Mar A Lago than Northwoods — are creatures of Trump’s takeover of American politics. If the midterms are any indication, voters have had enough of all that. If there’s one thing we learned Friday it’s that sweatpants come in handy when you have to sleep on the airport floor.