Home Part of States Newsroom
News
West Virginia Attorney General wants school funding lawsuit dismissed 

Share

West Virginia Attorney General wants school funding lawsuit dismissed 

Nov 17, 2026 | 3:35 pm ET
By Lori Kersey
West Virginia Attorney General wants school funding lawsuit dismissed 
Description
(Greenleaf123/Getty Images)

The office of West Virginia Attorney General JB McCuskey is asking the state Supreme Court to dismiss a legal challenge over the state’s school aid funding formula.

In a motion filed Friday on behalf of state officers named in the lawsuit, attorneys with McCuskey’s office argued that the state Supreme Court does not have authority over Senate President Randy Smith and House Speaker Roger Hanshaw, the two lawmakers named in the suit. They ask the court that the two be dismissed from the lawsuit. 

They also argue the petitioner, a sixth grade student in Lincoln County identified only as M.D., has not met the burden of showing standing to sue anyone. They separately asked the court to dismiss the lawsuit. 

“Her first theory — direct harm to M.D.’s education — fails because the Petition never ties that alleged harm to anything the State Officer Respondents did or anything a writ could make them do,” they wrote. “The second theory,  taxpayer standing, fails because M.D.’s mother hasn’t provided any evidence that she pays taxes to the State (let alone that M.D., the actual Petitioner, does).”

The lawsuit was filed in September on behalf of M.D. and the student’s parent, Lakin Patten, in an attempt to require state lawmakers to “correct the school funding formula.” The student is represented in the case by the American Civil Liberties Union of West Virginia. 

The lawsuit lists as defendants Hanshaw, R-Clay; Smith, R-Preston; Auditor Mark Hunt; Tax Commissioner Matthew Irby; Treasurer Larry Pack; the state Department of Education; the state Board of Education, the School Building Authority, State School Superintendent Michelle Blatt, as as well as Lincoln County school board officials and county officials.

State officials have asked the court to pause the case until April, giving lawmakers time to address the funding formula during the upcoming legislative session, when the formula is expected to be a focus. 

West Virginia public school poor finances have prompted a wave of school closures across the state. The West Virginia Department of Education says it will take a $410 million increase in state aid for public schools to meet needs in special education, enrollment stabilization, personnel and more. 

State school officials have agreed with the motion to delay the case, while officials for the Lincoln County school board took no position. 

Attorneys with the ACLU, on behalf of M.D., have argued against delaying the case, in a response filed Nov. 9.

“For years, West Virginia’s students and schools have been given false hope and empty  promises concerning reform to the school aid formula, always being told that an adequately funded education is right around the next corner….,” the attorney wrote. “The present action is before this Court because the wait was too long, the cost of inaction too high, to permit another legislative session to proceed without  clear guidance from this Court as to what is constitutionally required of the Respondents.”