Photojournalists sue St. Paul Police over use of force during ICE raid
Three Minnesota photojournalists have sued the St. Paul Police Department for its use of chemical munitions against the men during an immigration raid on Rose Avenue last November.
The officers shot pepper balls at the photographers, pepper sprayed them at close range and unleashed tear gas at the men, according to the complaint. The lawsuit argues the acts violate the First, Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments of the Constitution, and constitute assault and battery, among other violations.
On Nov. 25, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents attempted to arrest a man in the Payne-Phalen neighborhood of St. Paul, but he fled and holed up in his house. A crowd of protesters grew outside the home as ICE attempted to detain the man.
Sahan Journal’s Aaron Nesheim, MPR’s Kerem Yücel and freelancer Timothy Evans all arrived on the scene with press passes around their necks and large professional cameras. Evans wore a ballistic vest labeled “PRESS.”
St. Paul Police also responded to the scene. After ICE left with the detainees, protesters shouted at the local police to leave. As the St. Paul police officers left, they unloaded pepper balls, pepper spray and tear gas on protesters and journalists alike.
A St. Paul Police spokesperson said the department doesn’t comment on pending litigation. The St. Paul Police Civilian Internal Affairs Review Commission is still investigating the incident.
A police officer sprayed MPR photojournalist Kerem Yücel with pepper spray at close range while he was photographing the scene. Yücel inhaled and swallowed the chemicals, according to the complaint. Other officers shot him in the neck, shoulders and chest with pepper balls, the complaint alleges.
“At no time did (Yücel) demonstrate any conduct that would have suggested he was a protester, let alone engage in any hostile or threatening conduct towards law enforcement,” the complaint reads.
The three photographers stood together, off to the side of the crowd, at least 10 feet from the nearest protesters and out of the way of law enforcement. Nonetheless, police officers shot them with pepper balls and launched tear gas at them, according to the complaint.
Yücel struggled to breathe after the barrage of chemical munitions and was taken away from the scene in an ambulance. All three journalists suffered the effects of the chemicals on their eyes and airways. Evans was bruised for about a month from the impact of the pepper balls.
All three journalists needed mental health treatment in the aftermath of the events.
The lawsuit names St. Paul Police Chief Axel Henry, alleging that he failed to properly train and supervise his employees. The plaintiffs are seeking damages, attorney’s fees and an injunction barring the St. Paul Police Department from engaging in further unconstitutional conduct against them.