Home Part of States Newsroom
News
The companies Utah consumers complain about the most 

Share

The companies Utah consumers complain about the most 

Nov 16, 2026 | 7:02 am ET
By Sydnee Chapman, The Utah Investigative Journalism Project,Kayli Jacob, Utah Investigative Journalism Project
The companies Utah consumers complain about the most 
Description
A 2024 Utah law allows public access to consumer complaints against businesses that had at least 10 complaints filed against them within a 12-month period. (Illustration by Rachel Pixton for The Utah Investigative Journalism Project)

The following story was reported by The Utah Investigative Journalism Project in partnership with Utah News Dispatch.

A 78-year-old living on Social Security while battling leukemia who was left in a panic after a plumbing company turned his water off and left before finishing replacing pipes on his mobile home. 

A bedridden, elderly woman dependent on oxygen who was charged thousands of dollars for a toilet and sink unclogging. 

A homeowner who made payments on their newly installed solar panels for the better part of a year before discovering that the installation company never turned the panels on. 

These are a handful of the Utahns mentioned in complaints to the Utah Division of Consumer Protection after dealings with allegedly problematic companies in a state with a long-held reputation as the fraud capital of the United States. While the state Legislature passed a bill in 2024 making certain consumer complaints public, the change hasn’t had much impact on the average Utahn. 

“It’s probably not in consumers’ minds generally at this point because we haven’t really made anything public using this law yet,” said Blake Young, the division’s former deputy commissioner who recently left the agency. 

Prior to the 2024 law, complaints to the Utah Division of Consumer Protection were not public. The bill, however, pulled back the curtain. It allows public access to consumer complaints against businesses that had at least 10 complaints filed against them within a 12-month period. The division can also release them if it takes public action against a company or at the discretion of the division director. 

The Utah Investigative Journalism Project obtained 307 of those public complaints through an open records request. The complaints included at least nine different companies in the tech, construction and travel industries and represent over $5 million in disputed funds. Emerald Pools & Spas made up the largest chunk at over $1.6 million, followed by Private Label Accelerator at nearly $1.3 million and Action Heating, Cooling and Plumbing at over $850,000. 

Action Plumbing also garnered the lion’s share of complaints, at 45%, followed by Meta at 16% and Private Label Accelerator at 12%. 

A lawyer representing Action Plumbing said those figures don’t provide a “reliable or fair measure of a company’s service record” and that the state had “an aggressive campaign to solicit additional complaints.” 

The Division of Consumer Protection won a judgment against Parker Wilde, Private Label Accelerator’s owner, after filing a lawsuit alleging he scammed over 200 people out of several million dollars by offering help to set up automated Amazon storefronts that he claimed would generate passive income. 

Wilde, however maintains that the business wasn’t a scam and said the business settled “partially because it could not afford a defense and they sought tens of millions of dollars and we simply didn’t have those funds.” Instead, he said a number of factors, like rising manufacturing and shipping costs, contributed to the downfall of the business. 

“If I could have seen the future on how things in the e-commerce ecosystem would have changed so quickly — I would have never pushed the business,” Wilde wrote in a statement to the UIJP. “Again we are all saddened that it did not work out.” 

Meta did not respond to a request for comment for this story. Neither did Emerald Pools, which still owes customers millions of dollars and is pursuing bankruptcy.

Young said the 2024 change came about because of conflicting provisions in state law about which division records were public. He added that while the law hasn’t had much of an impact yet, it’s something the division wanted to have on the books due to previous cases where officials’ hands were tied. 

“We had some cases years ago where we would have loved to have been able to do this and it just was not a door that was open for us to do,” Young said. “So now that’s a thing that we have as a tool in our pocket that we can pull out if it’s the right way to approach a problem.” 

Available remedies  

What the division can do once someone has filed a complaint is dependent on each individual case.

“Every complaint that comes in has its own special adventure,” Young said. 

When the division receives a complaint it checks to see if a law was broken and if the division can do something about it. If so, an investigator reaches out to the consumer and the business to find out what happened. There are a handful of likely outcomes from there:

  • A business didn’t realize its actions had broken a law and will try to make things right with the customer.
  • The division can work out a resolution, similar to a settlement, where the business makes things right with consumers and sometimes pays a fine. Those fees do not go to the consumers themselves. 
  • If a resolution can’t be reached, the division can issue a citation, which is filed like a court case and gives the business the chance to attend a hearing with an administrative law judge. 
  • The division can file a civil lawsuit, typically in cases involving multiple victims, large amounts of money and some additional need for restitution for consumers. 
  • The division can file a criminal referral with a prosecutor. 

Young said civil lawsuits are expensive for the state and less common due to the limited number of state attorneys assigned to work with the Division of Consumer Protection. Even less common are criminal referrals. 

“In our administrative cases … where we have a citation and a hearing, we can only recover fines from the company in those, we can’t get money back to consumers,” Young said. “So the lawsuit process is usually what we look to more when there’s a lot of people who need money back.”

The division filed such a lawsuit against Private Label Accelerator that resulted in a $7.9 million judgment in fines. 

Consumer Protection has also partnered with the Division of Professional Licensing to revoke Action Plumbing’s professional licenses and demand fines and file legal proceedings against the business. Those actions are ongoing. An attorney for Action Plumbing said the company disputes the state’s allegations and looks forward to presenting its side during the case. 

Mathew Thue, assistant professor of business ethics at Weber State University, said protections for consumers often fall short, especially since there is a lot of gray area between what is allowed under law and what is a deceptive practice. 

“The framework is very far from a perfect protection,” he said. “When the rubber hits the road for an average person, I don’t think the regulators are there really anywhere in most cases to help very much.”

For example, a common complaint regarding Meta was individuals being locked out of accessing their account.

One consumer said they lost years’ worth of materials from their religious proselytizing account, as well as photos of their late wife, when their personal account was disabled without warning or the chance to appeal. In another complaint a consumer said their account was suspended for alleged child safety violations but they were unable to challenge these claims as an appeal would require them to log in to their suspended account. The complaint states this had happened once before and Meta restored the account previously after finding it was an error.  

Young said there are policies in place for when complaints are submitted by the government. He said that when the public submits these requests the question becomes more nuanced, delving into whether or not a practice is deceptive or not.

Several of the complaints also described paying for a multiyear cruise that after multiple delays appeared unlikely to ever set sail, leaving would-be passengers across the world out thousands. 

One Utah consumer reported waiting more than nine months to hear back from the cruise line about refunding the $25,000 they deposited toward the cruise. 

“I’m convinced that we unfortunately have also been scammed by depositing $10,000 for a deposit for a cabin as part of our dream of seeing the world on a residential cruise,” a separate complaint reads. “My partner even sold his house to make this a reality as he didn’t want to be an absentee landlord.”

Avoiding scams and fraud 

While there are remedies available to consumers who fall victim to scams or deceptive practices, the best protection is often avoiding them in the first place. 

The division tallied the top 10 areas of complaints from 2025. In order from most to least common, they are:

  1. Auto sales 
  2. Auto repairs
  3. Apartment/housing rentals
  4. Home remodeling/construction
  5. Solar
  6. Home furnishings
  7. Home alarm systems
  8. Healthcare billing
  9. Travel/vacations
  10. Gyms

Young said consumers can check the division’s website and social media accounts for updates about deceptive businesses, and that they should also verify who they are dealing with, especially as artificial intelligence evolves. 

“AI is making it very, very easy for scammers to operate,” he said. “There is almost no friction to create very convincing text messages, emails and phone calls, and even websites.”

For example, one of the complaints reviewed by the UIJP details a scam where two individuals pretending to be actors from the TV show “Chicago Fire” convinced a Utahn to send them $1,200 in gift cards as well as personal information like his bank account and Social Security number. 

The scammer “promised (the victim) he would come and get him and take him to Chicago to live with him,” reads the complaint. “Every single day the scammers reach out to (the victim) saying ‘I love you babe’ etc. … Please help show him he’s being scammed. He won’t stop sending everything he has to these people.” 

Other consumers complained of companies attempting to bully them into paying for more services.

One complaint describes an Action Plumbing employee coming to a client’s home after they fired the company over a botched job clearing a clogged sewer line that left a partially-collapsed, 14-foot hole in the client’s yard. 

“He started yelling at her and she retreated into her home to lock the door. He continued yelling and pounding on her door. She was home alone and very frightened, crying, and shaking (she is usually very brave), and had to call police to have them leave her home,” the complaint reads.

When asked about this case, Action said in an email from its lawyers that using a camera on the pipe can not always show the whole issue, and that the excavation company was licensed separately from Action. They attributed the issue to being asked to leave before the work was completed. 

Action said that when a representative returned to her home to speak to the owner “she became irate and apparently called an acquaintance of hers who was a police officer from another jurisdiction.” The officer threatened them with a restraining order and would not let the representatives remove their equipment, Action said. They said they have submitted a complaint against the officer, and have also provided supporting documents regarding this case to the Department of Consumer Protection in 2024.

Both Young and Thue said that if something sounds too good to be true, it likely is.

“If something ever just feels off, trust that feeling,” Young said. “It’s very important that whenever anyone is in a heightened situation, stop and think and try and get some time and space to think about whether that seems real or not.”

Several consumers in the complaints also reported feeling pressured or wary about interactions with the companies but pushing forward anyway. 

One reported that the estimate they received for a new AC was “sky high” but that they felt pressured to sign off the same day because a sales rep said there was only one unit left and it would sell before they called back. 

Another said an “extremely pushy” Action technician told them their electrical panel was in a severe state and posed a high fire risk.

“At the time, I felt their reasoning was not sound but felt pressured to decide,” the complaint reads. “I had to take out a loan from a third party as well as rely on financial assistance from my parents.” 

Action said their technicians allow clients to make their own decisions on purchases and services. “Action does not allow its technicians to ignore problems they see in a customer’s home. Action technicians are trained to inform customers of any issues they observe during their visit and provide the customer with options for how to address those problems,” Action said in an email, adding that the company had not received any complaints about the work done for the client who had to take a loan. 

“Action is committed to transparent and ethical business practices,” the lawyer wrote in an email. “Employees are trained to present options clearly so that customers can make informed decisions. When a situation genuinely requires prompt attention — such as an active leak or a safety concern — it would be irresponsible not to communicate that to the customer.”

The consumer reported to the state, however, that they were stuck in a broiling heat wave without air conditioning and felt like they had no options.

“I cried when I had to make this payment due to the extreme financial burden this would place on me,” the consumer wrote to state regulators. “The technician did not offer any smaller units, though they did use their iPad to explain why I needed a unit this large and expensive.”