Home Part of States Newsroom
Brief
Commonwealth Court Judge Lori Dumas announces candidacy for state Supreme Court

Share

Commonwealth Court Judge Lori Dumas announces candidacy for state Supreme Court

Nov 17, 2026 | 11:38 am ET
By Peter Hall
Commonwealth Court Judge Lori Dumas announces candidacy for state Supreme Court
Description
The Pennsylvania Supreme Court. (Jen Barker Worley/ Administrative Office of Pennsylvania Courts)

Commonwealth Court Judge Lori Dumas will run as a Democrat for state Supreme Court, for one of two seats expected to be up for election next year, she announced Monday.

Dumas has served on Commonwealth Court, one of Pennsylvania’s appellate courts, since she was elected in 2021. The winners of next year’s election will take the seats currently held by Justice Christine Donohue and Chief Justice Debra Todd.

“I’m running to be a justice on Pennsylvania’s Supreme Court because I believe Pennsylvanians deserve a justice who brings experience, independence, compassion, and an unwavering commitment to the rule of law to the bench,” Dumas said, adding that as a mother of three, her commitment to those ideals is deeply personal.

Commonwealth Court Judge Lori Dumas announces candidacy for state Supreme Court
Commonwealth Court Judge Lori Dumas. (Photo courtesy of the Administrative Office of Pennsylvania Courts)

The election will be another chance for Republicans to change the makeup of the court, which has had a majority of justices elected as Democrats since 2015. The retention election for three Democratic justices in 2025 prompted intense voter influence campaigns from outside groups that spent millions of dollars in addition to $14 million the justices’ campaigns raised.

The court now has four Democrats, two Republicans and one Independent. Justice David Wecht announced in May that he was leaving the Democratic Party over what he described as anti-Jewish actions and rhetoric becoming mainstream within the party.

Once elected, Pennsylvania judges must face voters in a retention election every 10 years to remain in office.

Todd, who was first elected in 2007 and retained in 2017, faces mandatory retirement in 2032.

“At the present time, the Chief Justice is not planning to seek retention in 2027,” court spokesperson Stacey Witalic said, noting Jan. 4 is the deadline for judges to file notices if they are seeking retention. 

Donohue, first elected in 2015 and retained in 2025, will reach the mandatory retirement age of 75 next year and must retire.

Before her election to Commonwealth Court, Dumas served for 19 years as a Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas judge, where she presided over family, civil and criminal cases.

“The law must work the same for everyone who walks into a Pennsylvania courtroom — no matter their ZIP code, their income, or their circumstances,” Dumas said, noting that as a trial court judge she protected children, families and victims of violence.

“I have been tasked with balancing the power of government with the voice of the people. I am running for the Supreme Court to bring that same fidelity to the law — and to every Pennsylvanian it serves,” she said.

The Supreme Court is the court of last resort in Pennsylvania, handling appeals ranging from death penalty cases to family court disputes. In recent years, the court’s role in redistricting has had an impact on the commonwealth’s representation in Congress and the General Assembly. 

The court also hears disputes over challenged laws and policy decisions, such as the court’s consequential ruling in June that skill games are illegal under the state Gaming Act and Crimes Code.