Alabama leads nation for arresting, punishing pregnant women, according to report

Tennessee, Alabama and South Carolina lead the nation in arresting and criminally punishing women for allegedly posing a danger to their fetuses, according to a report released by advocacy group Pregnancy Justice.

Nationwide, nearly 1,400 people were arrested or subject to disparate bail, sentencing and probation for conduct related to their pregnancies between 2006 and the Supreme Court decision in June 2022 dismantling abortion rights, the report found. The vast majority were poor, white women, though poor Black women were disproportionately represented.

The report found 649 pregnant women in Alabama had been arrested in the time period, the largest in the country and more than twice the numbers of the next two states combined.

“Alabama had far and above the highest number of pregnancy criminalization arrests, representing almost half (46.5%) of the total,” the report said.

South Carolina accounted for 180 of the cases. Tennessee accounted for 131.

“Pregnant people have been criminalized at an accelerating rate for actions that would not be illegal but for a person’s pregnancy,” Lourdes Rivera, president of Pregnancy Justice, told reporters on Tuesday.

The report shows a substantial increase in the number of people being charged for crimes tied to pregnancy. In 2013, Pregnancy Justice released a report that found that law enforcement had targeted 413 pregnant people between 1973 — which marked the Roe v. Wade decision legalizing abortion — and 2005. The new findings show those instances have tripled.

Advocates pointed to two key drivers in criminalizing pregnancy: the expansion of so-called fetal rights or “personhood” laws and a more punitive approach to substance use among pregnant women — even as many states move to decriminalize drug abuse in line with evolving approaches to  addiction. The majority of criminal cases documented by Pregnancy Justice related to substance use, including marijuana, cocaine or methamphetamines. In about one-quarter of these cases, the substance was legal: such as nicotine, alcohol or prescription opiates.

In Alabama, voters in 2018 approved a constitutional amendment saying it was public policy “to recognize and support the sanctity of unborn life and the rights of unborn children, including the right to life.”

In Tennessee, both factors hold true. Tennessee law says that “life begins at conception.”

Tennessee also became the first state in the nation to enact a “fetal assault law.” Enacted in 2014, the law allowed women to be prosecuted for drug use during pregnancy. The measure was criticized by state and national health and advocacy groups and was allowed to expire in 2016. Several efforts to reimplement the law have been introduced in the Tennessee Legislature since.

Nina Gurek, policy director for Healthy and Free Tennessee, said that despite the law’s expiration her organization continues to hear of prosecutions involving pregnant women on child abuse or neglect charges involving legal and illegal substance use allegations.

“We know it’s still happening,” she said.

The Pregnancy Justice report warns that more people could face criminal charges or increased bonds or sentencing as states have enacted abortion bans and restrictions.

Alabama’s near-total abortion ban only allows the procedure if a woman’s life is threatened. Tennessee’s strict abortion ban explicitly exempts pregnant women from prosecution for seeking abortions.

But Gurek said she places no trust in the law’s protections.

“When we talk about back alley or secret abortions, that’s not the real risk to people’s lives,” said Nina Gurek, policy director for Healthy and Free Tennessee. “It’s handcuffs.”

Editor Brian Lyman contributed to this report.Updated at 11:27 on Oct. 23 to correct the span of the report. It runs from 2006 to 2022, not 2005 to 2022.

Tennessee Lookout is part of States Newsroom, a network of news bureaus supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Tennessee Lookout maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Holly McCall for questions: [email protected]. Follow Tennessee Lookout on Facebook and Twitter.